0
Why were supreme court justices given tenure subject due to good behavior by the framers of the constitution?
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
to avoid direct political pressure from the supreme court. they are also allowed to resign instead of going through the impeachment process...three judges have done this - mark delahay, george english, and sam kent
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
The framers of the Constitution believed that granting Supreme Court justices tenure subject to good behavior would ensure their independence and protect them from political pressure. By giving justices lifetime appointments, they would be able to make decisions based on the Constitution and the law without fear of losing their positions due to political influences or popular opinion. This independence allows them to uphold the principles of justice and act as a check on the other branches of government.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why were supreme court justices given tenure subject to good behavior by the framers of the constitution?
to avoid direct political pressure from the supreme court. they are also allowed to resign instead of going through the impeachment process...three judges have done this - mark delahay, george english, and sam kent
How long can a supreme court judge rule?
Justices in the USSC are appointed for life. Supreme Court justices "shall hold their Offices during good Behavior" according to Article III, Section1 of the US Constitution. It's important to understand that while Justices may not be fired or removed from office, thay are subject to impeachment in the same manner and for the same causes that apply to the President of the United States in Article II.
How might the framers of the constitution have viewe public opinion polls?
They would probably have no problem with them. In the time of the Framers, colonist communities were very small and the Framers were easily approachable, living in their midst. The Framers therefore already had a pretty good idea what the public's opinion was on any given subject.
Can the Supreme Court rule on the Constitution?
No. According to Article VI, the Constitution is the "supreme law of the land" which justices of the US Supreme Court swear to uphold. The Constitution is the standard by which other legislation is judged; the Constitution itself is not subject to judicial review.For more information on this topic, see Related Questions, below.
What has the author Sidney H Asch written?
Sidney H. Asch has written: 'Civil rights & responsibilities under the Constitution' -- subject(s): Civil rights, United States - Constitution 'Mental disability in civil practice' -- subject(s): Forensic psychiatry, Insanity, Jurisprudence 'The Supreme Court and Its Great Justices' -- subject(s): Biography, United States, United States. Supreme Court
What has the author Leo Page written?
Leo Page has written: 'Justice of the peace' -- subject(s): Justices of the peace 'For magistrates and others' -- subject(s): Crime and criminals, Justices of the peace, Probation
What has the author S Ramaswamy written?
S. Ramaswamy has written: 'The English critical tradition' -- subject(s): Criticism, English literature, History and criticism 'Justices of the peace' -- subject(s): Justices of the peace
Can a President dismiss a member of the US Supreme Court and replace him with someone more in agreement with the President?
No, that would be unconstitutional. Article III of the Constitution provides that Supreme Court justices are appointed for life. One reason for this is to prevent each new Presidential administration from sweeping the Court of opposition. Doing so would eliminate the independence of the judicial branch, simply leaving it a political extension of the Executive branch, something the Framers believed would result in tyranny.Supreme Court justices can only leave the Court in one of four ways:ResignationRetirementDeathImpeachment (and conviction)The House of Representatives can only initiate impeachment proceedings for legitimate reasons, as outlined in the Constitution. Justices cannot be removed from the bench simply because other members of government disagree with their decisions.
What has the author Nikolaas Tinbergen written?
Nikolaas Tinbergen has written: 'Social behavior in animals, with special reference to vertebrates' -- subject(s): Animal behavior 'Bird life' -- subject(s): Bird watching, Birds, Behavior 'Animal behavior' -- subject(s): Animal behavior, Behavior, Animal 'Curious naturalists' -- subject(s): Behavior, Birds, Insects 'The animal in its world' -- subject(s): Animal behavior 'La Vie sociale des animaux'
What has the author Charles Sumner Lobingier written?
Charles Sumner Lobingier has written: 'The evolution of the Roman law' -- subject(s): History, Roman law 'American courts in China' -- subject(s): Exterritoriality, Consular jurisdiction, American Diplomatic and consular service 'A treatise on Philippine practice' -- subject(s): Evidence (Law), Municipal courts, Justices of the peace 'Obsolete features of our Federal Constitution' -- subject(s): Constitution 'The Evolution of the Civil Law' 'The people's law' -- subject(s): Legislation, Referendum
What has the author Niko Tinbergen written?
Niko Tinbergen has written: 'Estudios de Etologia 2' 'The animal in its world' -- subject(s): Animal behavior 'Social behaviour in animals with special reference to vertebrates' -- subject(s): Vertebrates, Social behavior in animals, Behavior 'An objectivistic study of the innate behavior of animals' -- subject(s): Animal behavior, Comparative Psychology, Psychology, Comparative 'Animal behavior' -- subject(s): Animal behavior, Juvenile literature, Animals, Habits and behavior, Diergedrag 'The behavior of the snow bunting in spring' -- subject(s): Snow bunting, Behavior 'Bird life' -- subject(s): Behavior, Birds 'Animal behaviour' 'Curious naturalists' -- subject(s): Insects, Entomology, Birds, Behavior 'The study of instinct' -- subject(s): Animal behavior, Animals, Habits and behavior of, Habits and behavior of Animals, Instinct 'The herring gull's world' -- subject(s): Birds, Herring gull, Behavior, Social behavior in animals, Habits and behavior, Herring-gull, Ethology 'Signals for survival' -- subject(s): Animal communication, Lesser black-backed gull, Birds, Behavior
What has the author F G Brennan written?
F. G. Brennan has written: 'An outline of the powers and duties of Justices of the peace in Queensland' -- subject(s): Justices of the peace
