Why would a boy break up with you because you're too sweet?

Answer 1

While there is nothing wrong with being "sweet" (cheerful, good-natured, or accommodating), some boys, average boys, could have difficulty dealing with a girl who is always nice to everyone, and helpful, and never mean, rude, or nasty.

In one case, the extroverted boy is concerned (too concerned) with his public image, with being around someone who is always better-liked, more popular, or more agreeable. This can highlight any flaws of his in these areas.

In another case, the introverted boy is concerned with your emotional well-being and his own. He would worry that you would never try to have your own way, or argue, or contradict his ideas. This could result in your becoming submissively miserable, or make him feel guilty for dominating you, even unintentionally.

Neither of these scenarios could be correct, but they are subjects for thought in relationships that include girls who may present as overly nice, sweet, or perfect.