0
According to Chief Justice John Marshall the power to tax involves the power to do what?
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
Destroy.
In McCulloch v. Maryland, 17 US 316 (1819), Marshall stated (excerpt):
"Upon the supposition, that the bank is constitutionally created, this is the only question; and this question seems answered, as soon as it is stated. If the states may tax the bank, to what extent shall they tax it, and where shall they stop? An unlimited power to tax involves, necessarily, a power to destroy; because there is a limit beyond which no institution and no property can bear taxation. A question of constitutional power can hardly be made to depend on a question of more or less. If the states may tax, they have no limit but their discretion; and the bank, therefore, must depend on the discretion of the state governments for its existence. This consequence is inevitable. The object in laying this tax, may have been revenue to the state. In the next case, the object may be to expel the bank from the state; but how is this object to be ascertained, or who is to judge of the motives of legislative acts?"
Marshall's point was that the State, which opposed the establishment of a national bank, if left unchecked by the federal government, had the ability to destroy the bank by taxing it out of existence.
Case Citation:
McCulloch v. Maryland, 17 US 316 (1819)
For more information, see Related Questions, below.
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
In worceter v. Georgia chief justice john marshall ruled that the state of Georgia?
In worceter v. Georgia chief justice john marshall ruled that the state of Georgia?
Which man served as chief justice of the United states supreme court?
which man served as chief justice of the united states supreme court
Who broadened the Supreme courts power?
Chief Justice John Marshall
How old was the youngest Chief Justice of the United States when he was appointed?
Chief Justice John Marshall was only 45 years old when President Adams appointed him to the US Supreme Court in 1801. Marshall served on the Court until his death in 1835, making him not only the youngest, but the longest-serving Chief Justice in US history.
Who was the supreme court justice for the Marbury vs Madison case?
Fourth Chief Justice John Marshall presided over the Court in 1803, when the case was finally allowed to go to trial. Chief Justice Marshall authored the opinion of the Court for Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803). Marbury v. Madison is the case most often cited when discussing the origin of judicial review.For more information about Marbury v. Madison, see Related Links, below.
Who was appointed Chief Justice to replace John Marshall?
Chief Justice Roger B. Taney replaced Chief Justice John Marshall after Marshall's death in 1835.
Who was the chief justice in 1819?
The Chief Justice of the United States in 1819 was John Marshall.
What tribe did Chief Justice John Marshall protect?
Chief Justice John Marshall tried unsuccessfully to get the federal government to protect the Cherokee Nation.
When did Chief Justice John Marshall serve?
Chief Justice John Marshall presided over the US Supreme Court from 1801 until his death in 1835.
What did chief justice Marshall's landmark decision to the power of federal government?
Chief Justice Marshall is best known for his opinion in Marbury v. Madison, (1803).
What was the Chief Justice Marshall's decision in the case of Marbury v.Madison?
The Court through Chief Justice Marshall unanimously decided not to require Madison to deliver the commission to Marbury.
In worceter v. Georgia chief justice john marshall ruled that the state of Georgia?
In worceter v. Georgia chief justice john marshall ruled that the state of Georgia?
Which Chief Justice was appointed by John Adam?
President John Adams appointed Chief Justice John Marshall in 1801.
What has the author Caroline Tucker written?
Caroline Tucker has written: 'John Marshall, the great Chief Justice' -- subject(s): Juvenile literature 'John Marshall, the great Chief Justice' -- subject(s): Juvenile literature 'John Marshall, the great Chief Justice' -- subject(s): Juvenile literature
Who became US chief justice in 1801?
John Marshall
Who was the chief justice in 1820?
John Marshall was the chief justice of the supreme court from January 31, 1801- July 6, 1835.
What Chief Justice of the US Supreme Court served more than 30 years?
john marshall was the supreme court chief justice for 34 not 35.
