answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

The failure of the Commonwealth, 1649-53

NMA hostility • Army believed C'wealth not radical enough

• Insufficient religious reform as the independents

wanted

• Suppression of the Levellers

• Rump especially alienated the army (pay & not sent

home/failure to 'heal & settle'/Dutch war meant

money not used in other ways)

Anglo-Dutch War • Meant more tax, inability to spend on widows

pensions/poor relief

Rump (i)

Unpopularity of

• Loss of army support (see above)

• Lack of any religious settlement

• Lack of radical political/legal/social reform after first

months

• MP's accused of working for their own gain

Rump (ii)

Treatment of

former royalists

• Loss of land

• Fines

• Failure to encourage "heal & settle"

Rump (iii)

confusion over

1653 elections

• = attempt to perpetuate itself

Cromwell's

position

• Dominates through personality, public stature, military

power

• As leader of army could use it to close/change sytems

at will

• Rump/Barebones always had to "look over their

shoulder" - no real freedom to act

Fear that radical

reform would

lead to a

conservative

reaction

• Rump especially was always concerned that to act too

radically would bring the enemies of Parliament

together and lead to opposition & possible unrest.

• Moderate/radical conflict in Barebones alarms

moderates so much that they close the barebones down

and hand back power

In conclusion, after the death of Charles, the Commonwealth system failed to

provide clear, effective government.

It was always envisaged that the Rump would be shortlived to prepare for a new

permanent way of governing the country. The early failure of the Commonwealth,

just speeded this up.

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What are the successes and failures of the commonwealth values put into practice by the commonwealth member states?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about American Government

The practice of one member of Congress supporting another member's pet project in return for support for his or her own project is known as?

logrolling


What does commonwealth state mean?

A commonwealth is any political entity that was founded on law and united by a compact for the good of the people.# The people of a nation or state; the body politic.# A nation or state governed by the people; a republic.# Commonwealth## Used to refer to some U.S. states, namely, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and Virginia.## Used to refer to a self-governing, autonomous political unit voluntarily associated with the United States, namely, Puerto Rico and the Northern Mariana Islands.# An international association such as The Commonwealth of Nations (formerly the British Commonwealth) or the Commonwealth of Independent States (former Soviet Republics).# The English state and government from the death of Charles I in 1649 to the restoration of the monarchy in 1660, including the Protectorate of 1653 to 1659.# Archaic. The public good; commonweal.


What does hot bunking mean?

Hot bunking is the sanctioned practice within military organizations of assigning more than one crew member to a bed or "rack" to reduce sleeping space. The practice dates back at least to the sixteenth century, and today is particularly applied aboard submarines, where maximization of space is especially important.


What is a Shadow Cabinet?

A shadow cabinet is a virtual and powerless government formed with members of the opposition. Where each member of the leading government has a opposite spokepeople. It is led by the Leader of the opposition. Its role is to criticize the goverment, and to have alternative propositions to the policies led by it. Actually, it mostly refers to the british opposition. But that form of representative opposition exists in several commonwealth countries, such as Canada.


Is Canada under British rule?

No. The French first settled there in 1605 followed by the British in 1763. In 1867 it became the Dominion of Canada. It is a member of the British Commonwealth. While Canada has the British Crowned Monarch as the head of state the Government of Canada is independent, autonomous and equal to the British Government, Australian Government or French Government.

Related questions

Is haiti a member of the commonwealth countries?

No, Haiti is not a member of the commonwealth countries.


Why is US not participating in the commonwealth games?

The US is not a member of the Commonwealth of Nations. Only members participate in the Commonwealth Games.Because the US is not a member of the Commonwealth


Is Pakistan a member of the British commonwealth?

Yes Pakistan is a member of the British Commonwealth


Is Guyana a member of commonwealth?

Guyana is a member of the Commonwealth, joined 26th May 1966


Is Chile a member of the British Commonwealth?

The organization once known as the British Commonwealth is now called the Commonwealth of Nations, and, no, Chile is not a member.


Does Italy participate in the Commonwealth Games?

No it does not. It is not a member of the Commonwealth.


Is Germany in the commonwealth games?

No it is not. Germany is not a member of the Commonwealth.


Who are the commonwealth forces?

Soldiers from member countries of Commonwealth form the Commonwealth Force. They are deputed for peace keeping in a commonwealth member country and are retained till the situation normalizes.


How many members are there in common wealth?

The Commonwealth of Nations has 53 member states. The Commonwealth of Independent States has 9 full member states.


Which commonwealth begins with a K?

Kenya was a member of the British commonwealth.


Is Brazil in the commonwealth games?

No, Brazil is not a member of the Commonwealth of Nations.


Is Turkey in the Commonwealth Games 2014?

No it is not. Turkey is not a member of the Commonwealth.