US v. Alfonso Lopez, Jr., 514 US 549 (1995)
The US Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in favor of Lopez, holding Congress had exceeded its power under the Interstate Commerce Clause by passing the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990. According to the Court, the government's convoluted argument that the Act was intended to reduce violent crime, which would have an economic impact on commerce between the states.
Majority (for Lopez)
Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist
Justice Sandra Day O'Connor
Justice Antonin Scalia
Justice Anthony Kennedy
Justice Clarence Thomas
Dissenting
Justice Stephen Breyer
Justice John Paul Stevens
Justice David H. Souter
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
can purpose amendments to the constitution to overturn a supreme court decision
Senate. The Senate must give a majority vote to approve a Supreme Court nominee.
More than likely, Supreme Court Chief Justice William Rehnquist was referring to the straw vote the court makes after hearing the oral arguments. Essentially, the court was not decided by the vote; it was simply the manifestation of the ruling.
Thomas was confirmed by a vote of 52-48, with Biden again voting nay.
On today's Court (2009), a 5-4 vote most likely means the Justices voted by political ideology, with Justice Kennedy as the swing vote. Split votes are common right now because the Court is ideologically polarized.
No, the Supreme Court is not elected by the people. Supreme Court Justices are nominated by the President, and then the Senate votes to confirm them.
swingvote
can purpose amendments to the constitution to overturn a supreme court decision
No, that's not true. Supreme Court justices have a right to vote, just like most other adult citizens.
The President
Senate. The Senate must give a majority vote to approve a Supreme Court nominee.
If your question refers to a state supreme court justice, and if your state provides for election to their supreme court rather than appointment, you can vote when you turn 18 (per the Twenty-Sixth Amendment of the US Constitution), provided you register properly before the election.If you are asking about US Supreme Court justices; they are nominated by the President and confirmed or rejected by Senate vote, not elected. The electorate (voting public) does not play a direct role in the appointment of justices to the US Supreme Court.
Direct popular vote (except supreme court).
weblog. Loads of gratitude sharing. cabcacfacbfedgad
vote for approval
US Supreme Court justices are chosen (nominated) by the President and approved by a simple majority vote of the Senate.
The selection of a supreme court justice is a two part system. First the president nominates an individual and then the Senate has a majority vote.