Why is water and sugar a mixture but not a compound?

Answer 1

Mixtures are heterogeneous forms of matter. Mixtures are composed of variable proportions of molecules and atoms.

Compounds are homogeneous forms of matter. Their constituent elements (atoms and/or ions) are always present in fixed proportions (1:1 depicted here).

Examples of mixtures:

• soil
• ocean water and other solutions
• air
• the cytosol of a cell

Examples of compounds:

• water (H2O)
• table salt (NaCl)
• sucrose (table sugar, C12H22O11)

Properties of Mixtures

• The composition of a mixture is variable.
• Each of its components retains its characteristic properties.
• Its components are easily separated.

Properties of Compounds

• The relative proportions of the elements in a compound are fixed.
• The components of a compound do not retain their individual properties. Both sodium and chlorine are poisonous; their compound, table salt (NaCl) is absolutely essential to life.
• It takes large inputs of energy to separate the components of a compound.

Separating the Components of a MixtureMost laboratory work in Biology requires the use of techniques to separate the components of mixtures. This is done by exploiting some property that distinguishes the components, such as their relative

• size
• density
• solubility
• electrical charge

DialysisDialysis is the separation of small solute molecules or ions (e.g., glucose, Na+, Cl-) from macromolecules (e.g., starch) by virtue of their differing rates of diffusion through a differentially permeable membrane.

An example:

Cellophane is perforated with tiny pores that permit ions and small molecules to pass through but exclude molecules with molecular weights greater than about 12,000. If we fill a piece of cellophane tubing with a mixture of starch and sugar and place it in pure water, the sugar molecules (red dots) will diffuse out into the water until equilibrium is reached; that is, until their concentration is equal on both sides of the membrane. Because of their large size, all the starch (blue disks) will be retained within the tubing.

ChromatographyChromatography is the term used for several techniques for separating the components of a mixture. Follow the links below for examples.Link to a description of paper chromatography, where the molecules are separated by size and solubilityLink to a description of exclusion chromatography, where the molecules in a mixture are separated by size.Link to a description of affinity chromatography, where molecules are separated on the basis of their attraction to material in the chromatographic column. ElectrophoresisElectrophoresis uses a direct electric current to separate the components of a mixture by the differing electrical charge.Link to a description of how the proteins in blood serum are separated by electrophoresis. Pure SubstancesSome of the pure substances isolated from mixtures cannot be further broken down. Oxygen (O2) is an example. It is one of the elements; the fundamental building blocks of matter.Link to discussion of elements.

Most pure substances are compounds. Table salt, sodium chloride (NaCl), is an example; water (H2O) is another. If we pass an electrical current through molten NaCl, two new substances will be formed:

• sodium, a shiny metal so reactive that it must be stored out of contact with the air
• chlorine, a yellowish poisonous gas.

In this operation, a compound has been decomposed into its constitutive elements.

Note the differences between separating the components of a mixture and those of a compound.

• The decomposition of NaCl required a large input of energy. This is because of the strength of the ionic bonds holding the Na and Cl atoms together.
• The ratio of the weights of the two products are always 23 parts of sodium to 35.5 parts of chlorine. This reflects:
  • the invariance of the ratio (1:1 in this case) of the number of atoms in a compound Link to discussion of valence.
  • the relative weights (23:35.5) of the atoms in table salt.
• The properties of the components of the compound are not the same as those of the compound itself. Both sodium and chlorine are hazardous to life; their compound, sodium chloride, is a vital ingredient of all animal diets.

Welcome&Next Search

Answer 2

Water and sugar are considered a mixture because they can be separated physically. In a mixture, the components retain their individual properties and can be easily separated using methods like evaporation or filtration. In contrast, a compound is a substance formed when different elements chemically combine, resulting in a new substance with unique properties that cannot be easily separated.