Cave City, KY and Horse Cave, KY
Erie, PA
Erie, CO
Summersville, WV
Ashton, WV
Erie, PA
Huntersville NC
Canfield, OH
North Carolina
Please edit your question to include states of these cities.
Verona, NY and Oneida, NY.
The halfway point between Lynchburg, VA and Rochester, NY falls in or around Mechanicsburg, PA, 17050.
The city that is approximately halfway between Hancock, Massachusetts, and Columbus, Ohio, is around the area of Erie, Pennsylvania. This location provides a central point along the route between the two locations. Depending on the specific route taken, other nearby towns may also be considered, but Erie is a notable halfway point.