Scrooge's punishment in "A Christmas Carol" can be seen as justified as it serves as a means to encourage his personal growth and redemption. Through experiencing the consequences of his actions and witnessing the impact of his behavior on others, Scrooge is able to reflect on his choices and ultimately make a positive change in his life.
I think this punishment depends upon severity of the crime..
Actually the opposite. According to God's law the punishment for sin is death.
Punishment can be justified ethically when it serves to uphold social order, deter harmful behavior, and promote rehabilitation. It can be seen as a means of restoring justice for victims and ensuring accountability for offenders. Additionally, if punishment is proportional to the offense and administered fairly, it can contribute to the moral development of individuals and society. Ethical frameworks, such as utilitarianism, support punishment if it ultimately leads to greater overall happiness and societal well-being.
The Supreme Court's ruling that chemical castration is a violation of the Eighth Amendment is justified because it prohibits cruel and unusual punishment.
Oedipus after he was blinded, while addressing to the people and himself declares that his punishment is less than justified.
It was Belle
The punishment of the Count of Morcerf in "The Count of Monte Cristo" can be seen as justified, given his betrayal of Edmond Dantès and the subsequent suffering he caused. Morcerf's actions, driven by greed and ambition, led to the wrongful imprisonment of an innocent man. However, some may argue that the severity of the punishment, including the public exposure of his past and the destruction of his reputation, raises ethical questions about vengeance and justice. Ultimately, it reflects the complexities of moral retribution in the narrative.
Ebenezer
Belle
Scrooge came from London
Bah....humbug
Jacob Marley