What comment could you write about a book?

Answer 1

If it is for a workshop in a class, be honest but not rude. People might not have too much self esteem regarding their work - so while it's important to be honest with your thoughts so that they can get an honest critique, it's also important that you're kind about it. Even if there isn't much you liked, make sure to say at least two or three things in the positive direction to offset all the negative. People can feel attacked if your critique is only a negative one, and you want them to be able to listen to your advice and not just reject it.

When giving your advice, show them certain parts that had the thing that you either liked or didn't like. Tell them what it was about it that you didn't like - "this phrasing made the line sound awkward" or "this made me feel sad, and it looks like you're trying to go for happy". Don't be afraid to make comments about structure and grammar, or to make assumptions and ask if they're right. If there was something you liked, don't be afraid to express just how much you liked it - it will make the author feel lovely, so don't be embarrassed.

The more you write, the more people will appreciate your comments. Don't skimp and just spend five lousy minutes on it. Take your time and comb through their work; they'll thank you for it when revising their piece.

Overall, just be honest! Remember that you're here to help them improve, and that they know that you're not obligated to love it. Don't be afraid to speak your opinions; people won't mind, as long as you're not mean about what you say.

Answer 2

This book is a captivating read that will keep you on the edge of your seat. The characters are well-developed and the plot is full of unexpected twists. Overall, it's a must-read for any book lover.