What would happen if a story didn't have a theme?

Answer 1

If it doesn't have a theme, it's not a story. The theme is what the story's about - either what the reader thinks the story is saying, or what the story actually is saying based on the evidence.

Answer 2

Without a theme, a story may lack focus and depth. Themes provide the central message or idea that the story conveys, helping to create meaning and resonance for the reader. A story without a theme may feel disjointed or lacking in substance.

Answer 3

Well, I don't think it's ever been accomplished, but you can certainly try. :)