Phoebe gets angry at Holden because he only names dead people, like Allie, and material possessions when asked to name things he likes. She feels he is being shallow and not acknowledging real, living people in his life that he cares about. Additionally, Phoebe might also feel hurt that Holden doesn't mention her in his list of things he likes.
4. Holden, DB, Phoebe, and Allie.
First of all, it made him bitter because he thought life was unfair since Allie didn't deserve to die. Secondly, it made him closer to Phoebe because Phoebe reminded Holden of Allie. Third, it made him closer to Jane, because she was the first person to really get close to him after Allie's death, which is why he was infatuated with her.
After Sunny leaves, Holden begins talking to Allie, his deceased brother.
Jane Gallagher Allie Caulfield Phoebe Caulfield The Ducks The Nuns
Holden's feelings for his deceased brother Allie and his sister Phoebe for sure, and possibly for Jane Gallagher, too.
One might get that vague impression from the book, yes, but the only two things that come through unambiguously about Holden's feelings for Allie were that he loved Allie very much, and was in a rage that Allie die so young.
Phoebe's statement suggests that Holden struggles to find joy or satisfaction in the events around him, indicating a general sense of dissatisfaction or disillusionment with the world. It hints at his tendency to be critical, pessimistic, or disconnected from the people and events in his life.
Allie's baseball glove symbolizes innocence, youth, and Allie himself as a pure and untainted soul. It serves as a reminder to Holden of the fragility of childhood and the loss of innocence as one grows older. The glove also represents Holden's desire to protect and preserve the innocence of children, including his younger sister Phoebe.
Allie is Holden's younger brother who passed away. His baseball mitt is special to Holden because it represents Allie's innocence and purity, and serves as a connection to his beloved brother.
Allie Holden's younger brother was named Phineas. He was a key character in the novel "Catcher in the Rye."
Allie is Holden's brother that died of leukemia. his mitt is special because he was really smart and ........
Holden is 13 years old when Allie dies. Reference : The Catcher in the Rye - Page 38