Is Jacob Black a Mary-Sue

Answer 1

YES! A BIG ONE!

(Main concepts that make up a Mary-Sue:)

•Name has a special meaning

•More unique than anyone else

•Is beautiful, but doesn't know it

•All boys are attracted to her

•Everyone loves her unconditionally (or hate her unconditionally)

•Love intrest only sees her

•Possess many talents

•Has no flaws

•Looks like the author but better

Lets see Bella Swan's results

•Her name "Bella" means "Beautiful" in Italian. Thereby "Bella Swan" actually means "Beautiful Swan."

Bella's story is based off The Ugly Duckling. She was a supposeably "plain" human being that turned out to be the most beautiful and graceful vampire there ever was. Aww how cute. So that's 1/9

•Bella is more unique than anyone else. Edward can't read her mind. In over 100 years he has never encounter another person whose thoughts she could not hear. Her blood has a floral aroma. So that's 2/9

•Bella describes herself as "ivory skinned", and "silm and slender", and other favorable terms like "translucent skinned" which all are positive considering this is a vampire novel, yet she goes on and says she skin is "unhealthy-looking", but our first impression was "ivory" and that's what the picture was painted. So that's 3/9

•When Bella enters Forks, five guys fall for her. Three ask her to the dance. So that's 4/9

•When she enters Forks High School, everyone wants to be her friend. Whoever hates her is because they're jealous like Lauren and Rosalie. 5/9

•Edward has never loved anyone in his entire undead life, despite being over 100 years old. 6/9

•Bella is an excellent student though she does little to no effort on actual school work. She loves to read, and she cooks all the meals for Charlie. Though she doesn't like it, she is good at it. 7/9

•Bella has no flaws. Sure yeah she's clumsy, but that doesn't count because it doesn't actually harm her in anyway. Does it make her the laughing stock of the whole school? Does it end up getting her picked on? No. Edward actually finds it adorable. So clumsiness is not a flaw for Bella Swan, it's a fakeout so that Meyer could say that Bella's not a self-insert, and that Bella is an independent character (which she's not!) 8/9

•On Meyer's website, she describes Bella as: fair-skinned, head that's heart shaped, chocolate brown eyes, straight brown hair, lips too full for her jawline, and has a willow's peak. Guess what? Meyer looks just like her! Except Bella is prettier (read the graphic novel) 9/9

Wow look at that. 9/9! This all proves that Stephenie Meyer is Bella Swan, and that not only is Bella Swan a self-insert, but a MARY-SUE.

Hope that answers your question.

Good day.

Answer 2

Since Jacob is a male character he would be a Gary-Stu if anything. The characters in Twilight do lack development but Jacob, at least, has some flaws and so isn't really a Gary-Stu. It depends what you personally consider a Mary-Sue/Gary-Stu.

Answer 3

No.