0
Roac advises Thorin to reconsider his stance towards the Lakemen, suggesting that they could be valuable allies rather than adversaries. He emphasizes the importance of diplomacy and warns that the dwarves might need the support of the Lakemen to secure their claim to the treasure. Roac encourages Thorin to show respect and understanding towards the Lakemen to foster a cooperative relationship. Ultimately, he highlights the necessity of unity in the face of potential threats.
What else can I help you with?
What wise advice did Roac give Thorin in the hobbit?
Roac, son of Carc, brought the news that the dragon Smaug had been killed in Lake-town by Bard the bowman.
Why do you think that Thorin would not listen to roac?
Thorin's refusal to listen to Roac stems from his deep-seated pride and determination to reclaim his homeland, which clouds his judgment. He is consumed by the desire to protect his treasure and assert his authority, making him dismissive of outside counsel. Additionally, Thorin's growing paranoia and obsession with wealth lead him to distrust even those who offer sound advice, viewing them as potential threats to his claim. This tragic flaw ultimately contributes to his downfall and the conflicts that arise among allies.
What does Roac warn them of?
Roac, the raven, warns Thorin and the dwarves of the potential dangers and consequences of their quest, particularly regarding the growing tensions with the elves and men over the treasure of the Lonely Mountain. He advises them to consider the political landscape and the need for diplomacy to avoid conflict. Roac emphasizes the importance of unity and caution as they seek to reclaim their homeland and wealth.
What function to the plot is served by the raven Roac?
In J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Hobbit," Roac the raven serves as a messenger and advisor to Thorin Oakenshield and his company. He provides crucial information about the state of affairs in the region, particularly concerning the reactions of other characters like the men of Lake-town and the elves of Mirkwood. Roac's presence emphasizes themes of communication and the interconnectedness of different races and their fates within the story. Additionally, he symbolizes the wisdom of nature and the importance of counsel in times of conflict.
Who is roac and why is he important to the dwarves in the Hobbit book?
Roac is a raven and the messenger of the dwarf king, Dain Ironfoot, in J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Hobbit." He plays a crucial role by delivering important news to Thorin Oakenshield and the dwarves regarding the growing threat of the elves and men after the treasure hoard in the Lonely Mountain is revealed. Roac's counsel and information help the dwarves navigate the political tensions surrounding their newfound wealth, emphasizing the importance of alliances and communication in their quest. His presence highlights the interconnectedness of different races in Middle-earth.
What wise advice did Roac give Thorin in the hobbit?
Roac, son of Carc, brought the news that the dragon Smaug had been killed in Lake-town by Bard the bowman.
Why does Thorin reject Roac's advice?
Because he doesn't believe that someone has defeated Smaug & that he is dead.
What did Thorin ask Roac to do?
Thorin asked Roac and the ravens to provide them information and carry messages. They brought the news the Smaug had been killed. They also took messages to Dain and kept them connected.
How old is Roac?
In Chapter XV, "The Gathering of the Clouds," Roac tells Thorin that "It is a hundred and three and fifty years since I came out of the egg;" in other words, Roac is 153 by the time of The Hobbit.
Why do you think that Thorin would not listen to roac?
Thorin's refusal to listen to Roac stems from his deep-seated pride and determination to reclaim his homeland, which clouds his judgment. He is consumed by the desire to protect his treasure and assert his authority, making him dismissive of outside counsel. Additionally, Thorin's growing paranoia and obsession with wealth lead him to distrust even those who offer sound advice, viewing them as potential threats to his claim. This tragic flaw ultimately contributes to his downfall and the conflicts that arise among allies.
What does Roac warn them of?
Roac, the raven, warns Thorin and the dwarves of the potential dangers and consequences of their quest, particularly regarding the growing tensions with the elves and men over the treasure of the Lonely Mountain. He advises them to consider the political landscape and the need for diplomacy to avoid conflict. Roac emphasizes the importance of unity and caution as they seek to reclaim their homeland and wealth.
Who is Roac from 'The Hobbit'?
An old raven, son of Carc, chief of all ravens.
Why do you think Thorin does not listen to Roäc from The Hobbit?
"Pride goeth before the fall." Dwarves are always being described as thick-necked, stubborn and prideful. Thorin Oakenshield can't just "let it go," when Roac suggests that he put aside his greed and share the wealth of Smaug's hoard.
What function to the plot is served by the raven Roac?
In J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Hobbit," Roac the raven serves as a messenger and advisor to Thorin Oakenshield and his company. He provides crucial information about the state of affairs in the region, particularly concerning the reactions of other characters like the men of Lake-town and the elves of Mirkwood. Roac's presence emphasizes themes of communication and the interconnectedness of different races and their fates within the story. Additionally, he symbolizes the wisdom of nature and the importance of counsel in times of conflict.
Who is roac and why is he important to the dwarves in the Hobbit book?
Roac is a raven and the messenger of the dwarf king, Dain Ironfoot, in J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Hobbit." He plays a crucial role by delivering important news to Thorin Oakenshield and the dwarves regarding the growing threat of the elves and men after the treasure hoard in the Lonely Mountain is revealed. Roac's counsel and information help the dwarves navigate the political tensions surrounding their newfound wealth, emphasizing the importance of alliances and communication in their quest. His presence highlights the interconnectedness of different races in Middle-earth.
Who does Smaug tell Bilbo not to trust?
Smaug tells Bilbo not to trust dwarves:In return for the excellent meal [of the Company's ponies] I will give you one piece of advice for your good: don't have more to do with dwarves than you can help!Smaug-The Hobbit: "Inside Information"
What piece of wise advice does roac the ancient raven have for thorin?
He said " to not trust the Master of the lake-men, but rather him that shot the dragon with his bow. Bard is he. of the race of Dale, of the line of Girion; he is a grim man but true.
