0
What else can I help you with?
Who did people vote on for the estates general?
In the Estates-General of 1789, people voted for representatives from three distinct estates: the First Estate (clergy), the Second Estate (nobility), and the Third Estate (commoners). Each estate had its own delegates, with the Third Estate representing the vast majority of the population. The voting process was marked by significant tensions, particularly as the Third Estate sought greater representation and eventually broke away to form the National Assembly, leading to pivotal changes in the French Revolution.
Why did representatives of the third estate insist that all three groups of Estates General meet and vote together?
Representatives of the Third Estate insisted that all three groups of the Estates General meet and vote together to ensure fair representation and to challenge the traditional voting system, which favored the First and Second Estates. By voting as a single body, the Third Estate aimed to amplify their influence, as they comprised the majority of the population yet had historically been outvoted. This push for unity was a pivotal moment that contributed to the broader demands for reform and ultimately the French Revolution.
Who was part of the third estate?
The third estate consisted of the commoners/peasants.
What estate does Maximilien Robespierre represent?
He came from the Third Estate. He was not a Noble nor a Clergy man
How did the bourgeoisie and the Third Estate change French society?
They defied the Monarchy and the Clergy and demanded a constitutional government.
Why were the representative of the Third estate disappointed with the pattern of voting in the Estate General?
Representatives of the Third Estate were disappointed with the voting pattern in the Estates-General because each estate had only one vote, which meant that the privileged First and Second Estates could easily outvote the Third Estate, despite its larger population. This unfair system reinforced the existing social hierarchy and marginalized the interests of the common people. The Third Estate sought more equitable representation and voting procedures, which contributed to their eventual push for reform and the French Revolution.
Why did the Third-estate propose a change in the Estate's-general's voting rules?
The system was that each estate took its own poll on a one-man-one-vote basis; the majority in each estate decided how that Estate should vote; and the final voting was by Estates. On tax questions, the Third Estate was bound to be outnumbered two to one, despiteits memebrs being far more numerous than those of the other two. Naturally, threfore, they wanted a single one-man-one-vote arrangement.
Why were the representatives of the Third Estate disappointed with the pattern of voting in the Estate General?
The representatives of the Third Estate were disappointed with the pattern of voting in the Estates General because each estate was granted one vote, which meant that the combined votes of the privileged First and Second Estates (clergy and nobility) could easily outvote the Third Estate, despite it representing the vast majority of the population. This unequal voting structure reinforced their marginalization and lack of influence in decision-making processes. The Third Estate sought a more equitable system, such as voting by head, which would allow their larger numbers to hold more weight in legislative matters. This frustration ultimately contributed to their decision to break away and form the National Assembly.
How had the first and second estates traditionally dominated the estates general?
By voting together. Senior clergy (Bishops and Abbots) were appointed by the King, and mostly of the nobility. They naturally voted with the nobility, giving them a two-to-one majority over the Third Estate; voting was not by head (the Third Estate was far more numerous) but by Estate.
Why was it that the Estates-General really did not help out the third class?
The trouble was the voting system. There were, of course, far more paople in the Third Estate, and it had far more delegates; but voting was not by head but by estates - so the other two could always outvote the Third.
Why did the third estate believe voting in the estates- general was unfair?
The Third Estate believed voting in the Estates-General was unfair because each estate had only one vote, regardless of its size or population. This meant that the First and Second Estates, which comprised the clergy and nobility, could easily outvote the Third Estate, representing the common people, despite them being the vast majority of the population. The Third Estate felt this system marginalized their voices and interests, leading to widespread frustration and demands for reform. Their discontent ultimately contributed to the outbreak of the French Revolution.
Why was the third estate locked out of the estate general?
The members of the Third Estate were arguing about the process for the Estates-General. The king's ministers had intended that the three estates meet and vote separately, with each estate having one vote. Instead, the Third Estate insisted that the three estates meet as one body, and that voting be by head so that each person have one vote (the Third Estate had as many members as the other two estates combined). When the deadlock over procedure could not be resolved, the members of the Third Estate declared themselves to be the only legitimate representative body, and renamed themselves the "National Assembly". They then vowed never to disband until they had written a constitution for France. They did this on 20 June 1789. The Third Estate invited the members of the other two estates to join them as part of the National Assembly, which they eventually did.
How did the third estate wat all the estates to vote?
The Third Estate wanted all estates to vote by head rather than by order, where each estate had one vote, which often marginalized their influence. They argued that since they represented the majority of the population, their votes should carry more weight. By advocating for this change, the Third Estate aimed to ensure greater representation and power within the Estates-General, highlighting the injustices of the existing voting system. This demand ultimately contributed to the broader revolutionary movement in France.
What were the greivances of the third estate during the french revolution?
They shouldered the entire tax burden of the nation and they were the largest group by population and were under represted when voting.
Who did people vote on for the estates general?
In the Estates-General of 1789, people voted for representatives from three distinct estates: the First Estate (clergy), the Second Estate (nobility), and the Third Estate (commoners). Each estate had its own delegates, with the Third Estate representing the vast majority of the population. The voting process was marked by significant tensions, particularly as the Third Estate sought greater representation and eventually broke away to form the National Assembly, leading to pivotal changes in the French Revolution.
Which Estate did the bourgeoisie belong to?
The Third Estate was the estate in which the bourgeoisie belonged to.
Why did representatives of the third estate insist that all three groups of Estates General meet and vote together?
Representatives of the Third Estate insisted that all three groups of the Estates General meet and vote together to ensure fair representation and to challenge the traditional voting system, which favored the First and Second Estates. By voting as a single body, the Third Estate aimed to amplify their influence, as they comprised the majority of the population yet had historically been outvoted. This push for unity was a pivotal moment that contributed to the broader demands for reform and ultimately the French Revolution.
