Why do some women keep diamond engagement rings if everything is called off?

Answer 1

Many people think that engagement rings should be returned to the guy. But some people hold a completely different view. They said 99% of the time, the break up is the guy fault. Also women time is more valuable than a guy. And what is more, every jewelry ring is custom to the girl, unless the ring is a ring passed down through generations. But all things should be discussed in advance!

Answer 2

There are several reasons why some women may choose to keep a diamond engagement ring even if the engagement is called off:

Emotional Attachment: The ring may symbolize a significant period in their life or the love they once shared, making it hard to let go, even if the relationship ends.

Legal and Cultural Norms: In some places, engagement rings are considered gifts that legally belong to the recipient, especially if the ring was given as a gift on a special occasion like a birthday or holiday.

Monetary Value: The ring often holds substantial financial value, and some women may see it as compensation for the emotional and social investment they made in the relationship.

Personal Choice: Some women may decide to keep the ring as a reminder of the lessons learned or as a part of their personal history, without any emotional attachment to the former relationship.

Sentimental Value: The ring might have been passed down as a family heirloom, or it may hold special meaning beyond the relationship, leading them to keep it.

The decision can be deeply personal and influenced by various factors, including the nature of the breakup, legal considerations, and individual feelings.