answersLogoWhite

0

Yes. A judge can direct the jury but cannot force them to a verdict. For example - the judge may say something like "..If you are satisfied the defendant acted maliciously, then you must find him guilty of murder. If not, then you must find him guilty of manslaughter..."

User Avatar

Wiki User

9y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Is a jury considered to have the case when a judge begins instructions during instructions or when instructions are finished?

When instructions are finished the jury begins deliberations.


Does jury instructions contain the judge's opinion of the evidence presented?

Jury instructions are presented by the judge to the jury. The judge explains what the laws are that govern the case at hand. Jury instructions define the elements of the charged offense and define the burden of proof. Each attorney gives the judge a set of proposed jury instructions. The judge considers each instruction and then decides which ones properly state the law that applies to the case. She then makes her instruction to the jury. The jurors must accept and follow the law as instructed by the judge and use that instruction in their deliberations as they weigh testimony and evidence presented at the trial. Jury instructions are not evidence.


Should a jury follow a judges instruction in reaching a verdict in a criminal case?

When a judge gives the jury "instructions," what that means is that the judge is "instructing" the jury on the applicable law or laws which the jury must consider in deliberating their decision. The judge is NOT instructing them on how to rule.


What kind of jury instructions does the judge give at the end of a criminal trial?

The judge will usually instruct the jury as to what evidence they may consider, and on definitions of key words that might appear in the titles of charges they can find the accused guilty or not guilty of. For instance, if a possible charge was "assault with great bodily harm," the judge might advise that constitutes "great bodily harm," e.g. broken bones, an injury requiring surgery, one that is life threatening or disfiguring, etc.


What is Judge's charge mean in a court of Law?

what is jury instructions in a federal negligence action/


What acts as the judge and jury?

Not surprisingly, a Judge and Jury act as judge and jury.


Why would someone have a trial be jury instead of a judge?

One may be attempting to appeal to the jury's sense of emotion; whereas, a judge will not give into emotions as easily.


What is the role of the judge in a jury trial?

In a jury trial, the jury determines what facts are true. The judge plays a referee and determines what is admissible at law, what law is relevant, and makes sure the trial is run by the rules. In a jury trial, the judge performs both roles.


Under what circumstances can a judge overrule a jury?

A judge can overrule a jury when there is a legal error in the jury's decision or if the judge believes the jury's decision is not supported by the evidence presented in the case.


Who enters the courtroom first judge jury?

Typically, the judge enters the courtroom first, followed by the jury. The judge takes their seat at the bench, and once the judge is in place, the jury is brought in. This order underscores the judge's role as the presiding authority in the courtroom. After the judge and jury are seated, the proceedings can commence.


What is a foreman?

a person of a jury picked by the jury or the judge


What is foreman?

a person of a jury picked by the jury or the judge