answersLogoWhite

0

The right to keep and bear arms.

The question that came is whether the 2nd Amendment was a "collective right," that is, a right guaranteed to the states (like the right to a republican form of government), or whether it was an "individual right" (like the right not to have one's home searched by the government absent a warrant.)

This question should have been settled when the U.S. Supreme Court heard United States v. Miller, 307 U.S. 174(1939), in which it was asked to decide whether a sawed-off shotgun was a legitimate weapon. If the 2nd Amendment was only a collective right, the Supreme Court would not have heard the case in the first place (Miller was not a State) and he wouldn't have had standing to raise the 2nd Amendment. However, Miller died before the case was heard, so his side did not send anyone to argue. As a result, 70 years of law on the subject went both ways in various courts,some deciding the Second supported only a collective right, while others deciding the Second fully supports an individual right, until the Supreme Court confirmed what it has always held, that the Second Amendment was an individual right.

NOTE: the debate on if this is just the militia or not is well settled in courts, that it is not - and several hundred pages of quotes can be put here by these courts:

All of the evidence indicates that the Second Amendment, like other parts of the Bill of Rights, applies to and protects individual Americans. We find that the history of the Second Amendment reinforces the plain meaning of its text, namely that it protects individual Americans in their right to keep and bear arms whether or not they are a member of a select militia or performing active military service or training. We reject the collective rights and sophisticated collective rights models for interpreting the Second Amendment. --- U.S. vs. Emerson, 270 F.3d 203 (5th Cir. 2001)

This decision differed from the other circuits who considered the Second was only a right of the states against the federal government depriving them of a militia, and not a right of individuals. The Supreme Court in Heller v. District of Columbia, 554 U.S. 570 (2008) found the rights under the Second Amendment are the rights of individuals, not a collective right or a right of the States.

Some wondered whether the Second Amendment was only applicable to Congress or was it also a right one could invoke against a state. The Supreme Court held the Second Amendment to be applicable to the states, McDonald v. Chicago, 561 U.S. ___, 130 S.Ct. 3020 (2010).

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

What picture can be drawn for amendment 2?

The second amendment is the right to bear arms. Which means you have the right to own a weapon to protect yourself. You could then, choose to draw a fire arm.


What right does the third amendment protect?

Your right to not house government officials or soldiers.


What freedom does the 2nd amendment protect?

Right to bear arms


Which right does the Fifth Amendment protect?

The fifth amendment protects many rights, but the most commonly known is the right of not incriminating yourself.


Which amendment of bill of rights protect freedom of speech?

The 1st Amendment gives each American the right to freedom of speech, religion and the right to free assembly.


What the purpose of the 2nd amendment?

The purpose of the 2nd Amendment is to protect the right of individuals to keep and bear arms. The Amendment was ratified on December 17, 1791.


The Amendment forced on Cuba after the war stated that the US had the right to send it troops to protect American property?

The Teller amendment


What is the purpose of the 2nd amendment?

The Second Amendment to the United States Constitution was designed to protect the right of American citizens to keep and bear arms. It was included to ensure that individuals have the means to defend themselves and their country.


Why is amendment 2 imporant?

The second amendment is the right to bare arms.


The first 10 amendment to the constitution protect individual right. what are they called?

the bill of rights


What does the second amendment protect?

This amendment speaks to state militias and the right to bear arms. Added: In a recent Supreme Court ruling the right of individuals to keep and bear arms (at least at the Federal level) was how the Amendment was interpreted.


What right is established by the 2nd Amendment?

The second amendment allows two things: -The right of the people to possess and own firearms. -The right of the states to raise militias. Such an amendment was meant to secure the rights of Americans from their own government, and to protect the country incase of a foreign, hostile invasion.

Trending Questions
What was a punishment for the deserters? What is the charge for presenting false evidence during a trial? May an action arising from negligence be waived? What was the legal alcohol consumption age in Texas in 1982? Are Business associates working on behalf of a CE are required to have a HIPAA certificate? After the preamble the rest of the US constitution is divided into what seven sections? Is it illegal to change multiple lanes at once while driving? What crime is a person guilty of if convicted for the FIRST time of operating a vessel while intoxicated in Missouri? How many ways are outlined by the Constitution for an amendment to be r how many ways are outlined by the constitution for an amendment to be ratified? It is illegal to cross over double double lines that are how may feet apart? What responsibilities does the insured party have in an insurance contract? What is the form called that the custodial parent wants to lower child support? My neighbor is taking phots and filming the backyard. It is hard to talk as the police have been contacted over claims of harrasment. Are they allowed to do this and what can be done to stop it? What is the time limit to respond to a subpoena duces tecum in Colorado? Who cannot file a civil libel? How many people work within this public service? Teenager wants to live with non custodial parent? How can you determine whether a state is safe or unsafe? What are the standard discovery requests in a debt collection suit? How can one become the executor of an estate after someone passes away?