Whose role is most problematic and controversial in plea negotiations?

Answer 1

The role of the prosecutor is often considered the most problematic and controversial in plea negotiations. Prosecutors hold significant power in determining charges, influencing plea deals, and recommending sentences, which can lead to pressure on defendants to accept deals even if they may not be in their best interest. This power imbalance raises concerns about fairness, coercion, and the potential for wrongful convictions, as defendants may feel compelled to plead guilty to avoid harsher penalties, regardless of their actual guilt.