0
Why is the constitutional convention method of amending the constitution controversial?
The constitutional convention method of amending the Constitution is controversial because it allows for a broad interpretation of what issues can be addressed, potentially leading to significant changes beyond the original intent of the Constitution. Critics worry that a convention could be dominated by extreme factions, risking the integrity of existing rights and protections. Additionally, there is uncertainty about the rules governing such a convention, raising concerns about accountability and the potential for a "runaway" convention that could propose sweeping reforms.
What else can I help you with?
Can something unconstitutional become constitutional?
Yes, by amending the Constitution.
How do you convene a constitutional convention?
In a nascent democracy the first step is to create and establish a process whereby delegates to a constitutional convention cam be selected. This can be a muddled affair. Who, for example, has the authority to convene such a convention? In a nation with an established constitution, that constitution should include the procedure for amending the existing constitution. A convention may be organized to propose amendments but there is still a ratification step whereby the constituent provinces or sub-states formally accept the constitution.
What are the two steps involving in the second method of amending the Constitution?
Article V of the U.S. Constitution allows amendments to be proposed by a constitutional convention called for by two-thirds of the state legislatures. This is a very uncommon method and has not been used for any of the present amendments.
What is the main idea of article 5?
The main idea of Article 5 is about the process and requirements for amending the United States Constitution. It outlines how amendments can be proposed and ratified either by Congress or through a Constitutional Convention, emphasizing the difficulty of changing the Constitution to ensure that it reflects the will of the people.
What is Article 5 of the Constitution outlines a second method for amending the Constitution?
a convention made up of two-thirds of the states can propose an amendment.
What is the process for amending the Virginia Constitution?
The process for amending the Virginia Constitution involves two main steps: proposal and ratification. An amendment can be proposed either by a two-thirds majority vote in both houses of the Virginia General Assembly or by a constitutional convention called by the General Assembly. Once proposed, the amendment must then be ratified by a majority of voters in a statewide referendum. This ensures that any changes to the constitution reflect the will of the people.
Article 5 deals with what concept?
amending the constitution amending the constitution
What are the two steps in the fourth method of amending the constitution?
An amendment can be proposed by a national convention and ratified by conventions in three fourths of the States.
What are the two steps in the third method of amending the constitution?
1. an amendment may be proposed be national convention. 2. then must be ratified by 3/4 of the state legislatures.
What is an amending formula?
An amending formula is a procedure for changing the Constitution.
What has the author John R Vile written?
John R. Vile has written: 'Pleasing the Court' 'The Constitutional Convention of 1787' 'Encyclopedia of constitutional amendments, proposed amendments, and amending issues, 1789-2002' -- subject(s): Constitutional amendments 'Essential Supreme Court decisions' -- subject(s): Constitutional law, Digests 'The Theory and Practice of Constitutional Change in America' 'Great American Lawyers' 'Contemporary questions surrounding the constitutional amending process' -- subject(s): Constitutional history, Constitutional amendments
What are two steps involved in the fourth method of amending the constitution?
The two steps in the second method of amending the Constitution are: proposal by Congress and ratification by conventions.
