0
Did Achilles and Agamemnon help start the Trojan war with King Menelaus?
Wiki User
∙ 14y agoWant this question answered?
Be notified when an answer is posted
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why does Hector feel he must fight Achilles?
I'm not going to delete that answer because it contains a lot of good information. 1. Achilles is not Achaean. The Greek army was often referred to by the Trojans as "Achaean" because it was led by Agamemnon, King of Mycenae... which is in Achaea. Achilles (like most of the other heroes of the Iliad) was a king in his own right, King of the Myrmidons, from the land of Phthia (were Mt. Othrys, ancient home of the Titans is located). 2. Achilles did not feel the war was unjust, however, he did not have the same motivation most of the others did. Many of the people fighting were fulfilling the Oath of Tyndareus (Helen's father). The Oath stated that the suitors of Helen would protect the chosen husband from anyone that quarreled with him. They also swore not to retaliate against the man chosen. Achilles was NOT one of the suitors, but Patroclus was. Additionally, the Myrmidons were the Spartans of the Bronze Age; the best warriors in all of Greece. Agamemnon indicated that they would be necessary for victory. 3. Agamemnon is not Helen's husband. Her rightful husband is Menelaus, who was selected by her father Tyrandeus, and made king of Sparta. Since she defied her father's wishes by remaining with Paris, she would have forfeited her claim to the throne. Besides, Tyrandeus named Menelaus King. After that Helen no longer mattered. 4. Achilles had taken a slave named Briseis as a concubine, while Agamemnon had taken Chryseis. Chryseis' father asked for her return and offered a ransom, but Agamemnon refused, causing her father to pray to Apollo to punish the Greeks. Apollo sent a plague among the men, and Agamemnon cunculted the prophet Calchas, who refused to speak unless Achilles protected him. Once he spoke, he told Agamemnon that he had to return CHryseis to her father to end the plague. To punish Achilles for intervening on Calchas' behalf, Agamemnon too Briseis away, at which point Achilles refused to fight further. -Indiriel ___________________________ Because he is a Greek (Achaean) and he does not want to kill his own people. Now that we have that settled, Achilles refuses to fight because he feels the war is unjust. Agamemnon had to return his concubine to her people, so he takes Achilles' concubine instead. Achilles felt the war was unjust and refuses to fight for Agamemnon at his point. Why? Well let's just take a step back for a bit here... why does The Trojan War start? Because Paris steals Agamemnon's wife and has an affair with her. The only reason Agamemnon wants Helen of Troy back is because without her, he loses his title as king, therefore Paris will become king. Agamemnon does not love Helen, he loves power. Therefore, Achilles does not want to fight an unjust war for a greedy man.
What is the subject of the lliad?
Homer's epic tale about the Iliad is all about how Paris ( Troy Prince ) abducted Helen, who was actually Menelaus's wife ( King of Sparta .) It is mainly about how The Greeks start a war because they want Helen back, but Paris will not give her back. In the end the Greeks create a wooden horse and hide all their warriors in it. The Trojans think that it is a gift from them and they want to end the war, and they start dancing and singing and celebrating. At night the Greek warriors jump out and burn down Troy.
How did the war in troy start?
In Greek legend, the Trojan War began when Paris, prince of Troy, stole away helen, wife of King Menelaus of Sparta. In Greek history, well, the Trojan war antedates written history, so the legend is our only guide. certainly there was a war; certainly Troy was destroyed. but for a woman? real life is rarely so romantic. The fact is almost certainly that Troy was positioned where its forces could restrict access for traders to the Black sea, and the Greeks wanted that access.
What does the Greek do when Achilles shows the body of hector?
In the Iliad, there is no indication that the Greeks were anything other than appalled at Achilles' treatment of Hector. While Hector was a significant enemy, Greek burial practices were strictly adhered to, and often truces would be made to allow for funeral rites to be observed. For Achilles to desecrate Hector's body (which was, in truth, not damaged because of the intervention of the gods), was a tremendous insult.
What is the resolution in the Iliad?
The theme of The Iliad is the rage of Achilles. The start of the resolution is when Priam and Achilles shared their grief together. It ends with Achilles giving the Trojans 12 days to mourn for Hector, showing that his anger is mostly gone.
How did paris start the Trojan war?
By running away with King Menelaus' wife, Helen.
Was Menelaus married to Helen?
Yes Helen was married to Menelaus and married also to Prince Paris of Troy and after his death to Deiphobus his brother, both sons of Priam King of Troy. After Deiphobus died at Menelaus's hands, he took back Helen as his wife as he had intended from the start of the Trojan war.
What country did Trojan war start?
the Trojan War was waged against the city of Troy by the Achaean's (Greeks) after Paris of Troy took Helen from her husband Menelaus, the king of Sparta.
How why did the Trojan war start?
Paris, the son of the King of Troy, seduced the wife (Helen) of a Greek king (Menelaus). Whether she went voluntary or not (Paris was supposedly the handsomest man ever) isn't well established, except that she looted the palace and took it off as a gift to Paris. Menelaus was brother to Agamemnon, the King of Kings of Greece. Agamemnon then raised an army and attacked Troy, to bring back Helen and of course the loot. Of course the opportunity to destroy a rival kingdom and sacking the rich city of Troy played a minor :) role.
Did the Minoans start the Trojan war?
The Trojan war was started when Paris (the prince of Troy and son of King Priam) visited Agamemnon and met Agamemnon's wife Helen. Helen was considered to be the most beautiful woman in all of Greece and Paris fell in love with her. He convinced her to escape with him to Troy and leave her husband. When Agamemnon discovered that Paris had taken her, he gathered a massive force and sailed for the city of Troy to retrieve her.
Who was really responsible for the Trojan war?
Eris goddess of strife and discord, because she is the one to start the golden apple argument, and have the Athena, Hera and Aphrodite start arguing for who should deserve the apple. This is the root cause of the Trojan war, which was caused by Eris. OR Paris because he took Helen from Menelaus so Menelaus got mad and started the war to get Helen and take the Trojans city, Troy
Why does Hector feel he must fight Achilles?
I'm not going to delete that answer because it contains a lot of good information. 1. Achilles is not Achaean. The Greek army was often referred to by the Trojans as "Achaean" because it was led by Agamemnon, King of Mycenae... which is in Achaea. Achilles (like most of the other heroes of the Iliad) was a king in his own right, King of the Myrmidons, from the land of Phthia (were Mt. Othrys, ancient home of the Titans is located). 2. Achilles did not feel the war was unjust, however, he did not have the same motivation most of the others did. Many of the people fighting were fulfilling the Oath of Tyndareus (Helen's father). The Oath stated that the suitors of Helen would protect the chosen husband from anyone that quarreled with him. They also swore not to retaliate against the man chosen. Achilles was NOT one of the suitors, but Patroclus was. Additionally, the Myrmidons were the Spartans of the Bronze Age; the best warriors in all of Greece. Agamemnon indicated that they would be necessary for victory. 3. Agamemnon is not Helen's husband. Her rightful husband is Menelaus, who was selected by her father Tyrandeus, and made king of Sparta. Since she defied her father's wishes by remaining with Paris, she would have forfeited her claim to the throne. Besides, Tyrandeus named Menelaus King. After that Helen no longer mattered. 4. Achilles had taken a slave named Briseis as a concubine, while Agamemnon had taken Chryseis. Chryseis' father asked for her return and offered a ransom, but Agamemnon refused, causing her father to pray to Apollo to punish the Greeks. Apollo sent a plague among the men, and Agamemnon cunculted the prophet Calchas, who refused to speak unless Achilles protected him. Once he spoke, he told Agamemnon that he had to return CHryseis to her father to end the plague. To punish Achilles for intervening on Calchas' behalf, Agamemnon too Briseis away, at which point Achilles refused to fight further. -Indiriel ___________________________ Because he is a Greek (Achaean) and he does not want to kill his own people. Now that we have that settled, Achilles refuses to fight because he feels the war is unjust. Agamemnon had to return his concubine to her people, so he takes Achilles' concubine instead. Achilles felt the war was unjust and refuses to fight for Agamemnon at his point. Why? Well let's just take a step back for a bit here... why does The Trojan War start? Because Paris steals Agamemnon's wife and has an affair with her. The only reason Agamemnon wants Helen of Troy back is because without her, he loses his title as king, therefore Paris will become king. Agamemnon does not love Helen, he loves power. Therefore, Achilles does not want to fight an unjust war for a greedy man.
What characters in literature have first names that start with the letter A?
Alice, Athena, Achilles, Arthur, Aphrodite, Abel, Archelous, Actaeon, Admetus, Aeneas, Agamemnon, Atreus, Amon, Ares, Argus, Aslan
Why did the Trojan war really start?
There were a couple of reasons. A simple one is that the Greeks of the time, the 13th-11th century BC Mycenaeans, were a people with war as a central part of their culture. A more politically complex reason does involve Helen of Sparta. Helen was the daughter of the king of Sparta. She may have been as beautiful as the myths claim, but truthfully it doesn't really matter. Whoever married her would inherit the throne of Sparta and become king. The man chosen to be her husband would only be king of Sparta as long as he was married to Helen. Menelaus, the brother of King Agamemnon of Mycenae, ended up marrying Helen and earning the throne. When Paris and Helen eloped, Menelaus knew he would lose the throne to Sparta. Getting support from his brother Agamemnon, who as ruler of Mycenae was interested in keeping Sparta under his control through Menelaus, Menelaus gathered allies and struck out against the Trojans.
Who was blamed for the Trojan war?
Oh, this is sooooo easy. Prince Paris of Troy and Queen Helen of Sparta. Paris took off with Helen. Her husband King Menelaus lauches one-thousand ships with the help of his brother King Agamemnon who rules all Greece. They start a war with Troy, Troy falls, Greece wins. Archilles dies.. it was basically Paris's fault. He took Helen with him to Troy.
How did Helen start the Trojan war?
According to Greek mythology, Helen of Troy was said to have been abducted by Paris, a prince of Troy. This act sparked the Trojan War as the Greeks, led by Agamemnon, sought to rescue Helen and avenge the dishonor done to her husband Menelaus. However, it is important to note that the Trojan War is a mythological event and may not have a historical basis.
How did the Trojan war start n the movie troy?
In the movie, Helen and Paris begin an illicit affair while he and his brother, Hector, are visiting Sparta to reaffirm peaceful relations between Sparta and Troy. They decide that she will come back to Troy with him, forsaking her vows to Menelaus. It wasn't until they were well underway that Hector discovered the truth and, to save both Paris and Helen from execution, decides to allow them to go back to Troy, knowing war will follow. In the movie, Agamemnon is portrayed as being a greater king than he was in the Iliad. In the movie, he uses Achilles to win battles against other city-states, forcing them to pay tribute to him and acknowledge him as high king. Agamemnon, uses his brother's anger to take war to Troy, with hopes of conquering the powerful and extremely wealthy rival city.
