answersLogoWhite

0

With its high ratings and countless parodies, it's unlikely that the words 'American Idol' do not ring familiar bells. The show, now in its fifth season, has ingrained itself into our everyday pop culture discourse and, as a result, we've learned new insults like 'That's bloody awful' courtesy of Simon Cowell. Thousands tune in on Tuesdays at 8:00 p.m. not only to watch those worthy of the spotlight sing their path to fame, but more importantly to watch Cowell mercilessly rip apart those he deems unworthy of it. He, like the other judges Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson, has never had a problem popping the dreams of the delusional. However the blunt insults that initially propelled the show to its popularity and appeal are now the same ones being called into question. Recently, a controversial clash occurred when the Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation accused Cowell and Jackson of making anti-gay remarks toward contestants on the show, many of which the group believes have been completely excessive and uncalled for. Take, for example, contestant Charles Barry to whom Simon commented, 'I don't mean this disrespectfully ... shave off your beard and wear a dress.' But how is that supposed to be taken respectfully? Cameras later followed Barry as he made a phone call on the brink of tears, which the show portrayed as funny. In another instance, after a male contestant finished singing, Cowell sarcastically remarked, 'Wonderful. Just what we needed, Sylvester Stallone's younger sister singing Paula Abdul.' And lastly, on another occasion, Jackson tactlessly asked, 'Are you a girl?' after contestant Zachary Travis (as evidently indicated in his name) had finished informing judges that he was a boy but often confused for a girl. 'The real offense here,' said GLAAD representative Damon Romine, 'was in the producers' decision to add insult to injury by turning a contestant's gender expression into the butt of a joke.' Lisa Gregorisch-Dempsey, senior executive producer of the television show 'EXTRA' argued, 'The critics totally miss the point. No one is exempt from the razor tongues of all three judges. Who goes on the show thinking it's a Miss Manners tea party?' Of course, viewers and contestants alike need to get over being excessively sensitive. It is a contest, after all, and the frankness and honesty being prescribed is sometimes what the contestants need to hear. There is, however, a way to deliver that message just as effectively without being unnecessarily cruel. Cowell or Jackson targeting an individual's gender is a step out of their criticism boundaries as singing judges. 'American Idol' is a show critiquing singing, not lifestyle choices. Especially with a show that is as widespread, culturally impacting and supposedly 'family-friendly,' as 'American Idol,' it is sad to see the standard of humor set so low‧humor that is cultivated at the expense of someone's dignity. There are those who argue that contestants place themselves into the situation, and by signing up are already aware of what they are getting themselves into. But many times, it is the way producers assemble the final cut of the show that is not made explicitly clear for contestants beforehand. For instance, Jack Marshall, founder and president of Proethics Ltd., pointed out, 'Obviously, they go to some of the worst contestants and tell them, we're going to give you one more chance. You didn't do so well. Here's a song we want you to sing. And they all sing the same song. And then, at the end of the show, the producers put together a montage of the most abysmal versions of a song like 'Fame.'' In these instances, contestants are completely unaware of how their video clips are being used. They are deceivingly pushed on by hope, only to be objects of ridicule. Since the accusations, Fox and 'American

User Avatar

Wiki User

16y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Do American Idol contestants go to school while competing?

yes


Is there a show for contestants to get on like American idol?

Yes you have to go to audtions on near your hometown. Go on American Idol and see if your home town is on there


How do you email the American Idol contestants?

Go to Yahoo or Google mail to email them and type this in the first sentence,"Dear Idol" or "Dear Idol cotestants".


How many American idol tour every year?

They said Alexis Grace was the last elimination and that the 10 left would go on tour. That would not include any former contestants who may also be included in the tour. The answer was just how many of the contestants from the 2009 season of American Idol will be on the next tour


Do the top 24 American Idol contestants go on tour?

No only the top 10 go on tour not even the top 13


American idol 2009 top 12 results?

Go to americanidol.com and you can see the 13 contestants for season 8


Who are the American idol top twelve season eight?

If you go to americanidol.com you will not only get the names , but also pictures and info about the new 13 contestants


Where can you see videos of contestants on 'Kokhav Nolad' 2010 - the Israeli equivalent of the 'American Idol' competition?

Click on the Related Link to go to the official page of Kochav Nolad.


Why do American idol contestants cry when they get voted off of the show?

Because they just got voted off..? It's the American dream to be up there on that stage! The earlier you go, the less of a chance you have to get a recording contract.


Who were the contestants on wheel of fortune on march 4 2014?

Only Jeopardy identifies the contestants Wheel of Fortne allows contestants indenties to go by there nickname or first name since it is a game of fortunes and they do not have championships or returning contestants like Jeopardy For Jeopardy it was Pam Mueller, a graduate student in psychology from Princeton, New Jersey Dan Melia, a retired professor from Berkeley, California Fritz Holznagel, a writer from Somerville, Massachusetts


Did trey songz go on American Idol?

No Akon did not go on American Idol. But my question is why can't Eben Frankewitz go back on American Idol next year?


Is American Idol?

if your question is what is American idol then this is the answer. American idol is a show that people compete in to become the next big singer. every Wednesday and Thursday they have all of the contestants go up and sing in frount of the judges. people call in to vote. the next day, the person that got the least amout of votes gets kicked off. they keep doing this till there is two left. then they crown their winner. hope this helps