answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

No. The way this is worded all x are y but not all y are necessarily x.

.

Example:

All Gorillas are Apes.

Some Apes are Chimpanzees.

Some Gorillas are Chimpanzees. (Not True)

.

All Dogs are Mammals.

Some Mammals are Cats.

Some Dogs are Cats. (Not True)

.

Analysis:

All A are B.

Some B are C.

Therefore, Some A are C.

.

∀x(Ax → Bx)

∃x(Bx ∧ Cx)

∴ ∃x(Ax ∧ Cx)

Truth Tree

..............................|Bn ET(n)

..............................|Cn ET(n) premise

............................./.\

.........................../....\

.......UT prem ~An / ......\

........................../\........\

......................../..\.........\

UT neg con ~An /.....\ ~Cn \ Bn UT prem

.............invalid ↑..... ↑...... /\

...................................../...\

.............................~An /......\ ~Cn UT negative conclusion

...................................↑.......x Invalid

Ignore the periods. The spaces were being deleted so I included periods to make the truth tree readable.

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Is this valid all x is y some y is z some x is z?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

Is this valid no x is y some z is x some z are not y?

It is logically valid but not grammatically.


What is the range of the equation y equals x - 4 - 12?

-8


What are the properties of equality and their explanation?

Equality is a binary relationship, defined on a set S, with the following properties:Reflexivity: x = x for all x in the set S.Symmetry: if x = y then y = x for all x, y in S.Transitivity: if x = y and y = z then x = z for all x, y and z in S.


What are the properties of multiplications with their meanings?

The properties of multiplication need to be considered in the context of the set over which this operation is defined.For most number systems, multiplications isCommutative: x*y = y*x for all x and yAssociative: (x*y)*z = x*(y*z) so that , without ambiguity the expression can be written as x*y*z for all x, y and zDistributive property over addition or subtraction:x*(y+z) = x*y + x*z for all x, y and zIdentity Element: There exists a unique element, denoted by 1, such that1*x = x = x*1 for all xZero element: there is an element 0, such that x*0 = 0 for all x.In some sets, an element x also has a multiplicative inverse, denoted by x-1 such that x*x-1 = x-1*x = 1 (the identity).


If x and y and a be three non-empty sets such that a intersection x equals a intersection y and a union x equals a union y then prove that x equals y?

Let x, y, and a be sets and X,Y,x',y' be elements. Denote X *x as X in (is an element of) x, I as intersection, and U as union. If we can show that for all X *x, X *y (and similarly, if for all Y *y, Y *x), then we are done. Case 1) xIa is empty Then x, a and y, a have no elements in common. So, if xUa and yUa are equal, then for all y' *yUa but y' not*a, y' *y. Since xUa and yUa are equal, either y' *a or y' *x. But we supposed y' is not*a, so y'*x. Similarly, for all x' *x, x'*y. QED Case 2) xIa is non-empty Define a' as a - {x| x *xIa}. Then xIa' is empty, and you can use the same prove as above, replacing a with a'. QED


Does x-y equals y-x for all x plus y values?

No. In fact, under normal rules of operation, x-y equals y-x only when x = y.


What is the x coordinate for all y-intercepts?

The x coordinate for all y intercepts is 0, just as the y coordinate for all x intercepts is 0.


What is the union of X and Y?

The union of sets X and Y is the set consisting of all elements that belong to X, or belong to Y or to both.The union of sets X and Y is the set consisting of all elements that belong to X, or belong to Y or to both.The union of sets X and Y is the set consisting of all elements that belong to X, or belong to Y or to both.The union of sets X and Y is the set consisting of all elements that belong to X, or belong to Y or to both.


Is this a function y equals x?

Yes, y =5 is a constant function. Meaning that for any value of x (in the domain), the value of the function (y) is 5. The graph would be a horizontal line five units above, but parallel to, the x-axis. Another answer: The above comments are only valid if we specify that x is just some constant. In general, however, when we refer to the function y=f(x)=x we do not mean a constant function, but rather a diagonal line running through the origin. The function would be a constant function if it were y=f(x)=c for some c, but normally when we write y=x we mean that the value of y is the value of x, and hence y changes as x changes.


What point is not located on x - axis or the y - axis coordinate grid?

All points with x and y that are both non-zero!All points with x and y that are both non-zero!All points with x and y that are both non-zero!All points with x and y that are both non-zero!


How do you simplify x plus y all over x ALL OVER x to the negative 1 plus y to the negative 1?

(x + y) / (x-1 + y-1) = (x + y) divided by ( 1/x + 1/y)Multiply numerator and denominator by 'xy' :xy (x + y) / (y + x)Then the whole thing falls apart, and we're left with:xy


What is the rule if x is 80 and y is 1?

There are infinitely many rules. SOme of these are: y = x/80 y = 80/x y = x + 79 y = 81 - x y = sqrt(x+1) - 8