Should insanity be avalid argument in a murder case?

Answer 1

Yes, insanity can be a valid argument in a murder case, as it addresses the defendant's mental state at the time of the crime. If a person is deemed legally insane, they may lack the capacity to understand the nature of their actions or differentiate right from wrong, which can absolve them of criminal responsibility. However, this defense must be rigorously evaluated through psychological assessments and legal standards to ensure its legitimacy. Ultimately, the use of the insanity defense highlights the complex interplay between mental health and the law.