no!
Well they were on The X Factor uk so if they couldn't sing then they would have been thrown out at the start and wouldn't have come 3rd. It's controversial to think they can sing or not.
In week 10 of "The X-factor" (2010), One Direction performed "She's the One" with Robbie Williams.
NO, one direction and cimorelli did not sing togather
One direction was formed in the show X-factor. First Harry, Louis, Liam, Zayn, and Niall had to audition and sing a song. From there on, they all passed and they were formed.
Sing
Torn
no one just themselves
100
"Torn "on x - factor
what makes you beautiful
Judges houses week(:
chasing cars
They sang "Total Eclipse of the Heart"
week 1 at the uk x factor
ON the last when they announced they were leaving 1D out.
Forever Young
niall and liam