answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

That's tricky. It depends on what the other notes (either around or in combination) are; it's a context thing. In other words, it would depend on the harmony and how the note was being used. For example:

Lets say the root of the I chord (here, an E Major triad) was going up in a chromatic line to the notes E#, G# and B, to make a #I diminished triad (E#°) that wants to resolve up to the IIm chord (the F# minor triad) - then the root of that second chord would be an E# - because it is acting like a raised tonic degree [ in solfege the "do" is raised to a "di" ].

However, if the notes F, A and C are used (an F major triad) then we here this as a bII chord (a flat two chord - a type of seconady dominant) which will want to resolve downward to the I chord (the E major triad). Here, we hear the note as a lowered second degree [ in solfege the "re" is lowered to "ra" ]. Again, it depends on context and where that chord (or even just the single note) resolves to to understand what to technically call it.

Having said all that, there could be a flat II diminished chord (in theory) and most people are okay with the enharmonic ambiguity because F is an easier note to conceptualize (for many people) than the note E#. But it usually comes down to the context of usage of the note in question; in other words - it could be either depending on how it's being used.

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: In the key of E Major is it better to write an E Sharp or an F Natural?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Music & Radio

What are the sharps in the key of A major?

it depends on what key its in. Theres not specific sharps for the bass cleff, it changes according to the key just like treble. If your in the key of c, then theres none. If your in the key of G, then theres one sharp (Fsharp)... etc etc.


Why is there no such thing as a B sharp or E sharp?

B# and Cb are used in music, just not very much. Most keys do not use either notes, but some do, and they can be used as accidentals. In this way they are similar to double-sharps and double-flats.


What is the key signature for G major?

Bbb Eb Ab Db Gb Cb Fb. Far from being strictly theoretical, the key F flat major becomes important when a composition in Cb major modulates to the Subdominant, the second most common modulation. The key-change may be indicated either through accidentals (double-flats placed beside notes), or through a change of key signature. While some composers might write a sonata in the key of Cb major, they might wish their second movement to be in the Subdominant key. They have the option of notating with a key signature of 8 flats (which shows the relation to the first movement), or using it's enharmonic equivalent, E major (key signature: 4 sharps), to simplify reading.


What comes before a note that has a sharp natural or a flat?

Normally, nothing... or (I guess) the note that came before that one. You write the accidental first and then the note, so nothing concerned with a note comes before its' accidental.


Where is A key signature placed on the staff?

The key signature of G sharp major is 8 sharps. The eighth sharp changes F# to F double-sharp (F## or Fx). This is a useful key, being the Dominant of both C# major and C# minor. If a composer were to write a Sonata in C# minor, but wished his second movement to be in the Dominant Key, he might use G# major, with 8 sharps, in order to express the relation of the first and second movements. Or he might choose to notate his second movement in A flat major, to simplify reading. Here are notes of the G# major scale: G# A# B# C# D# E# F## B# The scale of G# major may occur within any composition, but especially those composed in C# major or C# minor, since modulation to the Dominant is the most common modulation. However, the key change is usually indicated by the use of accidentals rather than a change of key signature. A practical application of the Key of G sharp minor can be found in early editions of the Beethoven Piano Sonatas. However, most modern editors change the key signature to A flat major, to simplify reading.

Related questions

How do you construct g major using accidentals?

Instead of writing a sharp in the key signature, write one next to the F when you write out the scale.


How To Write E Minor Scale?

An E natural minor scale is written with a one-sharp key signature, so you just write out the scale in semibreves and add an additional D sharp for the harmonic minor, and two additional sharps to the sixth and seventh degrees when ascending in the melodic minor (C sharp and D sharp). You lower the sharps and revert back to the natural minor when you descend through the scale.


Is there any way to write an A natural without having to cancel the A flat from my key signature - I'm are in Eb major?

No, you'll have to write the accidental for the A natural.


What are the keys in sharps and in flats?

C major (no sharps or flats)Sharp Keys:G Major/E minor (1 sharp)D Major/B minor (2 sharps)A Major/F-sharp minor (3 sharps)E Major/C-sharp minor (4 sharps)B Major/G-sharp minor (5 sharps)F-sharp Major/D-sharp minor (6 sharps)C-sharp Major/A-sharp minor (7 sharps)Flat Keys:F Major/D minor (1 flat)B-flat Major/G minor (2 flats)E-flat Major/C minor (3 flats)A-flat Major/F minor (4 flats)D-flat Major/B-flat minor (5 flats)G-flat Major/E-flat minor (6 flats)C-flat Major/A-flat minor (7 flats)These are all the possible keys you can write in, enharmonic keys are italicised.


What are the different signatures and keys of music?

There are a total of fifteen keys in Western music. Keys come with two forms, sharp keys and flat keys and one comes with all naturals. The complete list of major keys are shown below: C major (or A minor) - no sharps/flats G major (E minor) - 1 sharp D major (B minor) - 2 sharps A major (F-sharp minor) - 3 sharps E major (C-sharp minor) - 4 sharps B major (G-sharp minor) - 5 sharps F-sharp major (D-sharp minor) - 6 sharps C-sharp major (A-sharp minor) - 7 sharps F major (D minor) - 1 flat B-flat major (G minor) - 2 flats E-flat major (C minor) - 3 flats A-flat major (F minor) - 4 flats D-flat major (B-flat minor) - 5 flats G-flat major (E-flat minor) - 6 flats C-flat major (A-flat minor) -7 flats There you go, those are all the different keys you can write in!


What are the sharps in the key of A major?

it depends on what key its in. Theres not specific sharps for the bass cleff, it changes according to the key just like treble. If your in the key of c, then theres none. If your in the key of G, then theres one sharp (Fsharp)... etc etc.


What inspired Charles Darwin to write?

A fascination with the natural world, animals and plants and geology and his major discovery, his hypothesis of Natural Selection and Evolution of Descent with Modification!!


How do you write a coin changer program in C Sharp for GBP?

Take a penny, put it in a bank, and the coin will change into something better thanks to inflation.


What did the Mesopotamians write with?

sharp pointy objects


What are sharp pencil used for?

It can be used to write boldly, or such.


Why is there no such thing as a B sharp or E sharp?

B# and Cb are used in music, just not very much. Most keys do not use either notes, but some do, and they can be used as accidentals. In this way they are similar to double-sharps and double-flats.


What is the key signature for G major?

Bbb Eb Ab Db Gb Cb Fb. Far from being strictly theoretical, the key F flat major becomes important when a composition in Cb major modulates to the Subdominant, the second most common modulation. The key-change may be indicated either through accidentals (double-flats placed beside notes), or through a change of key signature. While some composers might write a sonata in the key of Cb major, they might wish their second movement to be in the Subdominant key. They have the option of notating with a key signature of 8 flats (which shows the relation to the first movement), or using it's enharmonic equivalent, E major (key signature: 4 sharps), to simplify reading.