answersLogoWhite

0

Octahedral vs. tetrahedral

So far, we've seen the Crystal Field Theory in action in octahedral, tetrahedral and square planar complexes. But how do we tell whether a particular complex is octahedral, tetrahedral, or square planar? Obviously if we know the formula, we can make an educated guess: something of the type ML6will almost always be octahedral (there is an alternative geometry for 6-coordinate complexes, called trigonal prismatic, but it's pretty rare), whereas something of formula ML4will usually be tetrahedral unless the metal atom has the d8electron configuration, in which case it will probably be square planar.

But what if we take a particular metal ion and a particular ligand? Can we predict whether it will form an octahedral or a tetrahedral complex, for example? To an extent, the answer is yes... we can certainly say what factors will encourage the formation of tetrahedral complexes instead of the more usual octahedral.

Generally speaking, octahedral complexes will be favoured over tetrahedral ones because:

  • It is more favourable to form six bonds rather than four

  • The crystal field stabilisation energy is usually greater for octahedral than tetrahedral complexes.

Remember that Δois bigger than Δtet(in fact, Δtetis approximately 4/9 Δo). If we make the assumption that Δtet= 4/9 Δo, we can calculate the difference in stabilisation energy between octahedral and tetrahedral geometries by putting everything in terms of Δo.

For example: for a d3octahedral configuration, the CFSE is -1.2 Δo(refer back to theTableif you like).

For a d3tetrahedral configuration (assuming high spin), the CFSE = -0.8 Δtet

Remember that because Δtetis less than half the size of Δo, tetrahedral complexes are often high spin.

We can now put this in terms of Δo(we can make this comparison because we're considering the same metal ion and the same ligand: all that's changing is the geometry)

So for tetrahedral d3, CFSE = -0.8 x 4/9 Δo= -0.355 Δo.

And the difference in CFSE between the two geometries will be 1.2 - 0.355 = 0.845 Δo.

If we do a similar calculation for the other configurations, we can construct aTableof Δo, Δtetand the difference between them (we'll ignore their signs since we're looking for the difference between them).

We can then plot these values on a graph.

Notice that:

  • The CFSE favours octahedral over tetrahedral in most cases, but the degree of favourability varies with the electronic configuration. In other words, for d1there's only a small gap between the oct and tet lines, whereas at d3and d8there's a big gap

  • For d0, d5high spin and d10, there is no CFSE difference between octahedral and tetrahedral.

  • The ordering of favourability of octahedral over tetrahedral is:

    d3, d8> d4, d9> d2, d7> d1, d6> d0, d5, d10

  • The units of the graph are Δo. So if we have strong field ligands present, Δowill be bigger anyway (according to the spectrochemical series), and any energy difference between the oct and tet lines will be all the greater for it. A bigger Δomight also push the complexes over to low spin. Similarly, as we saw previously, high oxidation states and metals from the 2nd and 3rd rows of the transition series will also push up Δo.

On the other hand, if large or highly charged ligands are present, they may suffer large interligand repulsions and thus prefer a lower coordination number (4 instead of 6). Consequently if you set out to make something that would have a tetrahedral geometry, you would use large, negatively charged, weak field ligands, and use a metal atom with a d0, d5or d10configuration from the first row of the transition series (though of course having weak field ligands doesn't matter in these three configurations because the difference between oct and tet is 0 Δo).

As the following Table shows, you can find tetrahedral complexes for most configurations, but there are very few for d3and d8.

d0

MnO4-

d5

MnCl42-

d1

TiCl4-

d6

FeCl42-

d2

Cr(OR)4

d7

CoCl42-

That's about it for the crystal field theory.Lecture 4starts by discussing how we actually make transition metal complexes, and this leads on to a section about stability constants.

Back toteaching resourcespage

This page was written by Dr Mike Morris, March 2001

Last updated March 2012

User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago

What else can I help you with?

Continue Learning about Natural Sciences

What is the no of octahedral voids per atom in ccp structure?

In a CCP (face-centered cubic) structure, each atom is in contact with 12 other atoms. This means each atom is surrounded by 12 octahedral voids. Therefore, the number of octahedral voids per atom in a CCP structure is 12.


What is the no of octahedral voids per atom in cubic close packed structure?

In a cubic close-packed structure, each atom is in contact with 12 nearest neighbors. Each of these atoms has an octahedral void at its center. Therefore, the number of octahedral voids per atom in a cubic close-packed structure is 12.


Is diamond octahedral or tetrahedral?

Diamond has an octahedral structure, meaning it is composed of two interpenetrating face-centered cubic lattices.


Why is an octahedral void called octahedral?

An octahedral void is called "octahedral" because its shape resembles an octahedron, which is a polyhedron with eight triangular faces. In a crystal lattice, these voids are formed at the center of an octahedral arrangement of atoms, where six atoms are positioned at the corners of the octahedron. This geometric configuration allows for efficient packing and coordination of atoms in a crystalline structure. The term reflects both the shape and the spatial arrangement of the surrounding atoms.


MgO has the stacking sequence of .AcBaCb. n.What is the coordination geometry around O2- anions in the lattice A- Tetrahedral B- Square planar C- Octahedral D- Trigonal Prismatic E- Linear F- Trigona?

C- Octahedral. In the .AcBaCb. stacking sequence, the oxygen anions are surrounded by 6 magnesium cations in an octahedral coordination geometry.

Related Questions

Can atoms occupy both tetrahedral and octahedral void simultaneously?

No, an atom cannot occupy both the tetrahedral and octahedral voids simultaneously in a close-packed structure such as a crystal lattice. Each void space can only accommodate a specific number and arrangement of atoms based on the structure of the lattice.


Which interstial site is larger octahedral or tetrahedral?

Octahedral sites are larger than tetrahedral sites because octahedral sites have more space available for an atom or ion to occupy. This is because octahedral sites are formed by six atoms or ions arranged in an octahedral shape, while tetrahedral sites are formed by four atoms or ions arranged in a tetrahedral shape.


What is the minimum distance between two tetrahedral voids in face centered cubic?

The distance between two tetrahedral voids is 0.866*edge length of the cube.As tetrahedral voids are present at 1/4th of the distance from each corner on a body diagonal of a cube.On each body diagonal there are two tetrahedral voids so making a total of 8 tetrahedral voids in an FCC cube. the distance between two tetrahedral voids is half of the body diagonal of a cube and the body diagonal of a cube is1.732 times of the edge length of the cube


What is radius ratio in tetrahedral voids?

0.225


What is the no of octahedral voids per atom in ccp structure?

In a CCP (face-centered cubic) structure, each atom is in contact with 12 other atoms. This means each atom is surrounded by 12 octahedral voids. Therefore, the number of octahedral voids per atom in a CCP structure is 12.


What is the no of octahedral voids per atom in cubic close packed structure?

In a cubic close-packed structure, each atom is in contact with 12 nearest neighbors. Each of these atoms has an octahedral void at its center. Therefore, the number of octahedral voids per atom in a cubic close-packed structure is 12.


Is diamond octahedral or tetrahedral?

Diamond has an octahedral structure, meaning it is composed of two interpenetrating face-centered cubic lattices.


What is the arrangement of atoms in a crystal lattice that allows for the presence of both tetrahedral and octahedral holes?

The arrangement of atoms in a crystal lattice that allows for the presence of both tetrahedral and octahedral holes is known as a close-packed structure. This structure consists of layers of atoms packed closely together in a repeating pattern, creating spaces where smaller atoms can fit into either tetrahedral or octahedral positions.


What do you mean by stellated truncated and dualized platonic solids and what are some real world examples of one of these?

starred lopped and betwolied same-shapely wholies *octahedral crystals in cubic voids *cubic crystals in octahedral voids *paper and wooden models


What are the differences between a tetrahedral hole and an octahedral hole in crystal structures?

In crystal structures, a tetrahedral hole has four neighboring atoms or ions surrounding it, while an octahedral hole has six neighboring atoms or ions surrounding it. This difference in coordination number affects the size and shape of the holes, as well as the types of ions that can fit into them.


Why is an octahedral void called octahedral?

An octahedral void is called "octahedral" because its shape resembles an octahedron, which is a polyhedron with eight triangular faces. In a crystal lattice, these voids are formed at the center of an octahedral arrangement of atoms, where six atoms are positioned at the corners of the octahedron. This geometric configuration allows for efficient packing and coordination of atoms in a crystalline structure. The term reflects both the shape and the spatial arrangement of the surrounding atoms.


MgO has the stacking sequence of .AcBaCb. n.What is the coordination geometry around O2- anions in the lattice A- Tetrahedral B- Square planar C- Octahedral D- Trigonal Prismatic E- Linear F- Trigona?

C- Octahedral. In the .AcBaCb. stacking sequence, the oxygen anions are surrounded by 6 magnesium cations in an octahedral coordination geometry.