0
Why does Montague say that romeo should be pardoned for killing Tybalt?
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
Montague says that Tybalt would have died anyway for killing Mercutio. Therefore, he says that Romeo should be pardoned for killing Tybalt, as the law would have sentenced Tybalt to death and Romeo was simply acting out that sentence.
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why does Montague say Romeo should be pardoned for killing Tybalt?
By fighting with Mercutio, Tybalt incurred the death sentence according to the edict promulgated by the Prince in Act 1 Scene 1 which made fighting in the streets a capital offence. Montague argues that Tybalt's life was forfeit anyway and that Romeo was just carrying out the sentence of the law.
How does Tybalt recogonize romeo at the party?
tybalt recognized romeo at the party
Why does Montague say he should be pardonned for killing Tybalt act 3 scene 1?
At the end of Act III Scene 1 of Romeo and Juliet, the Prince, who represents the law, holds a trial to determine what to do about the killing of Tybalt. Back in Act I he made a decree that people fighting in the streets would be put to death. Mrs. Capulet, Tybalt's auntie, takes the part of prosecutor. Montague, Romeo's dad, takes the part of defence counsel. Benvolio is the chief witness, and gives his evidence truthfully as we know because we are also witnesses to what happened.Mrs. Capulet, for the prosecution, says that Benvolio is not an impartial witness, and even so he admits that it was Romeo who killed Tybalt. Probably, she says, a bunch of Montagues jumped poor defenceless Tybalt. She concludes with the ringing "Romeo slew Tybalt; Romeo must not live."The Prince is, however, prepared to accept Benvolio's account. How, he asks, should we deal with the fact that Tybalt had only minutes before killed Mercutio in a different street brawl. Defense Counsel Montague hears his cue and speaks up. By killing Mercutio in a street brawl, Tybalt broke the same law that is being urged against Romeo, he says, so Tybalt's life was forfeit in any case. Romeo was just doing what the Prince's hangman would have been required to do eventually. However he also mentions that Romeo was Mercutio's friend. This is probably a bad move strategically, since it suggests that Romeo's motive was not enforcing the law but revenge for the death of his friend (as is in fact the case). This "getting revenge for my friend" thing is what keeps fuelling the feud. The Prince cannot pardon Romeo completely under these circumstances; he can only commute the sentence.
How does benolio defend Romeo's actions?
He explains to the prince that Tybalt would have been killed anyway (for killing mercutio). And that Romeo simply just saved him the trouble by killing him himself. Romeo should have been killed for killing Tybalt, but because Benvolio reasoned this with the prince, the prince only banished him(which is being pretty nice).
What is Lord Montagues' reasoning in his attempt to persuade the prince not to kill Romeo for killing Tybalt?
What argument does Friar Laurence use to prevent Romeo from killing himself? Juliet is alive, He should be happy for being bannished and not killed, and Tybalt could have killed him(Romeo) and not the other way aroundHe convinces Romeo to believe he is in a good position because he is only banished, not facing a death sentence, and that after a while they can convince Prince to let him back into Verona where he can meet Juliet.His first argument is "Be a man!" He follows this up with "Things could be worse."Things could be worse. Tybalt could have killed him.Friar says that Romeo should be happy to be just banished from fair Verona instead of killed and that it is not everyday that the prince makes such a merciful judgment, he also says that why should Romeo kill himself to make his wife Juliet even more heart broken.
Why does Montague say Romeo should be pardoned for killing Tybalt?
By fighting with Mercutio, Tybalt incurred the death sentence according to the edict promulgated by the Prince in Act 1 Scene 1 which made fighting in the streets a capital offence. Montague argues that Tybalt's life was forfeit anyway and that Romeo was just carrying out the sentence of the law.
How does Tybalt recogonize romeo at the party?
tybalt recognized romeo at the party
How Does Tybalt Recongnize Romeo?
by his voice: "This, by his voice, should be a Montague"
How does Tybalt recogze romeo in sc 5?
By his voice. "This, by his voice, should be a Montague."
What does lady Capulet want Montague to remember?
Lady Capulet wants Montague to remember that Tybalt, her nephew, was killed by Romeo, and she feels that Romeo should be punished for his actions. She believes that justice needs to be served for the death of Tybalt.
Who says This by his voice should be a Montague. Fetch me my rapier boy in Romeo and Juliet?
This quote is spoken by Tybalt in Shakespeare's play "Romeo and Juliet." Tybalt says this line to indicate that the person speaking with the soft voice should be a Montague, the rival family of the Capulets. He then asks for his rapier, indicating his readiness for a fight.
What conflict does Juliet have when she finds out that Romeo killed Tybalt?
Tybalt is her cousin. Romeo is her husband. Her mother and her nurse are angry at Romeo for killing Tybalt. Should she be angry also or stick by her man?
What is the prince's reason for allowing romeo to live after killing Tybalt?
Tybalt had broken the law by killing Mercutio and so should have been put to death anyway. However, it wasn't Romeo's job to put him to death.
Why did prince order Romeo's exile and not his death?
Montague, who acts as Romeo's advocate at the trial, argues that Tybalt had already broken the law and incurred the death penalty by killing Mercutio. Romeo was therefore only carrying out the law by punishing Tybalt. "His fault concludes but what the law should end, the life of Tybalt." The Prince has no desire to encourage vigilante justice, so he does not acquit Romeo on this plea, but only reduces his sentence from death to banishment
Why should Tybalt be angry that Romeo is at the ball?
Tybalt should be angry because Romeo is a Montague, and the Capulets and Montagues are feuding families. Seeing Romeo at the ball is a direct challenge to the Capulet family and their honor, adding insult to injury.
Why does Montague say he should be pardonned for killing Tybalt act 3 scene 1?
At the end of Act III Scene 1 of Romeo and Juliet, the Prince, who represents the law, holds a trial to determine what to do about the killing of Tybalt. Back in Act I he made a decree that people fighting in the streets would be put to death. Mrs. Capulet, Tybalt's auntie, takes the part of prosecutor. Montague, Romeo's dad, takes the part of defence counsel. Benvolio is the chief witness, and gives his evidence truthfully as we know because we are also witnesses to what happened.Mrs. Capulet, for the prosecution, says that Benvolio is not an impartial witness, and even so he admits that it was Romeo who killed Tybalt. Probably, she says, a bunch of Montagues jumped poor defenceless Tybalt. She concludes with the ringing "Romeo slew Tybalt; Romeo must not live."The Prince is, however, prepared to accept Benvolio's account. How, he asks, should we deal with the fact that Tybalt had only minutes before killed Mercutio in a different street brawl. Defense Counsel Montague hears his cue and speaks up. By killing Mercutio in a street brawl, Tybalt broke the same law that is being urged against Romeo, he says, so Tybalt's life was forfeit in any case. Romeo was just doing what the Prince's hangman would have been required to do eventually. However he also mentions that Romeo was Mercutio's friend. This is probably a bad move strategically, since it suggests that Romeo's motive was not enforcing the law but revenge for the death of his friend (as is in fact the case). This "getting revenge for my friend" thing is what keeps fuelling the feud. The Prince cannot pardon Romeo completely under these circumstances; he can only commute the sentence.
What does romeo do when Tybalt returns to the scene?
When Tybalt returns to the scene, Romeo arrives and tries to reason with him and prevent a fight. However, Tybalt taunts Romeo and challenges him to a duel. In a moment of passionate anger and grief over Mercutio's death, Romeo ends up fighting with Tybalt and kills him.
