answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

For two reasons. First, the source--a ghost is pretty weird and could be a hallucination or a vision implanted by the devil. Second, the consequences--if he believes the ghost he should kill the king and his own uncle. But if the ghost is wrong he will have committed regicide and have murdered his own stepfather, a crime at least as bad as Macbeth's murder of Duncan. It's not something you do lightly and on fishy information.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

The ghost looks like Hamlet's father but he only has the ghost's word for what he really is. Hamlet realizes that he is a little vulnerable, and thinks that possibly the ghost could be the work of the devil, designed to push Hamlet into doing something wrong by killing an innocent man who is his close relative and his king to boot. That's what Macbeth does and nobody thinks he's a good guy for doing it. Being tricked by putting your trust in the wrong person is what happens to Othello and nobody would want to go down that road.

Hamlet's words are: "The spirit that I have seen may be the devil, and the devil hath power to assume a pleasing shape. Yea, and perhaps out of my weakness and my melancholy (as he is very potent with such spirits) abuses me . . . to damn me."

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

"Foul play". He says "My father's ghost in arms. All is not well. I doubt some foul play. Would the night were come. Till then sit still my soul. Foul deeds must rise, though all the earth o'erwhelm them, to men's eyes." When he says "doubt" he means "suspect". The last line is inverted to get a rhyme (since it ends the scene) and really means "Foul deeds must rise to men's eyes though all the earth overwhelm them." By "foul deeds" and "foul play" we infer that he suspects the murder of his father by his uncle already. Hence he says "oh, my prophetic soul" when the ghost tells him so much.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why is Hamlet so unwilling to trust what the ghost tells him?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Performing Arts

What does a ghost do on a plane?

he dances the tango trust me i know i went to collage and also am a ghostr


Why are Rosencrantz and Guildenstern unable to find out What is wrong with Hamlet in Act 3 Scene 1?

They actually try to find out what is wrong with Hamlet in an earlier scene, Act II Scene 2. In Act III Scene I they make their report to Claudius of what they have found, or rather what they have not found. They do not tell Claudius the real reason they have not found it out, because the real reason is that they were so inept in their investigations that Hamlet almost immediately said "The king put you up to this, didn't he?" and after that they realized that they couldn't trust anything he said.


Would the king rather have Hamlet stay at Elsinore or return to Wittenberg?

Well, I must first of all say that my statement is of my own interpretation of the story. However, it may be possible that Claudius was planning on killing off Hamlet (or at least spy on him) from the very beginning. By looking at Claudius's personality, namely his willingness to kill for power, it can be implied that Claudius is fearful of loosing his power in the same way. Of all that may pose a threat to Claudius, Hamlet seems to be the most likely threat as he is in direct line to the throne (after all why not kill off the king and become the new king a little ahead of schedule?). So due to Claudius's paranoid nature, it may be possible that he intended to keep Hamlet in Elsinore so that he could plot to get rid of him.


How did Ophelia betray Hamlet's trust?

In what they call the Nunnery Scene, in Hamlet Act 3 Scene 1, Hamlet gets angry at Ophelia. The scene is very complicated and it is difficult to find a consistent explanation of the lines. In one theory, Hamlet becomes mad at Ophelia because he thinks she's become Claudius's courtesan. The situation is that Hamlet knows he was summoned there by Claudius. Claudius, himself, tells us that he summoned Hamlet. Hamlet finds Ophelia there, and then she returns the gifts he gave her, so Hamlet thinks Ophelia is returning his gifts because Claudius told her to. That's how it looks to him. Hamlet thinks he was summoned there by Claudius so Ophelia could return his gifts. Thus, Hamlet suspects that Ophelia must have gone over to Claudius. Hamlet thinks the same kind of thing has happened again that he's already seen, that being, first his mother went to Claudius and married him, then Hamlet's old friends R & G went to Claudius and started working for him, so now Hamlet thinks it's happened with Ophelia, too, when she returns his gifts, after Claudius summoned him there. And why would a lecherous old king be interested in a pretty young girl? Hamlet draws the obvious conclusion. He's gotten the tragically wrong idea that Ophelia is a prostitute. Here is another possible interpretation of what is going on. Hamlet expects Claudius to be behind the curtains and knows he is there watching this. He bumps into Ophelia. There is a lot he'd like to say to Ophelia, but he has to be careful because he is being overheard. She is going to return love-tokens to him (she is in fact doing this because her father told her to do it) His first thought is to deny it; he doesn't want Claudius to know about Ophelia and him. Then he thinks she is behaving oddly "Are you honest?" and she gets worried. Is he on to her? Hamlet then tries to tell her to get out of his life because he is too dangerous, and retire to a convent. "Why would thou be a breeder of sinners?" Then something happens, and he asks the question, "Where is your father?" Her answer gives away the fact that she knows that Polonius is behind the arras--she knew it all the time. Here he was trying to be nice to her, and she was selling him out. He is furious and instead of telling her to get to a "nunnery" that is a convent he tells her to get to the "nunnery" that is a brothel, because she had sold herself out like a prostitute. Ophelia certainly is Claudius's and Polonius's tool. She has engaged Hamlet in conversation knowing that the purpose of the thing is to trap him in front of the hidden witnesses. She has sold out to Claudius just like Rosencrantz and Guildenstern and Gertrude have. But she has done so because she is very weak, dependent and somewhat dimwitted, and she is trying to be a dutiful daughter and obey her father, without reflecting on what this might mean for Hamlet, or that it implies choosing sides in some court intrigue. When she finds that out, it will drive her mad. Hamlet is wrong about Ophelia, but he doesn't know that. She hasn't really gone over to Claudius. However, Hamlet's mistaken idea makes him very angry.


What events led to Hamlets death?

Hamlet love for his father plays a main part in his downfall. he struggles to come to terms with his fathers death and when he see's him he promises to avenge his murder. he does so privately because he can not trust anyone. because of this he is slowly driven to insanity.

Related questions

What' does distrusted mean?

unable or unwilling to trust


What does Ophelia tell Claudius about hamlet?

Assuming you are talking about Act II, Ophelia describes how Hamlet came to her chamber, looking disheveled and unkempt, looking depressed, unable to speak, but looked at her, sighed, and wandered away, distracted.


In Hamlet who was loyal to hamlet?

Hamlet's friend Horatio was most loyal to him. Furthermore, in Act 1, scene 5, Hamlet makes Horatio and Marcellus swear loyalty to him and to never reveal what they have witnessed in the woods and Hamlet's interaction with his father's ghost.


When was Never Trust a Ghost created?

Never Trust a Ghost was created on 1969-10-12.


What does Agamemnon tell Odysseus in Hades?

Agamemnon the ghost, tells Odysseus how he died, and also warns Odysseus not to blindly trust his wife Penelope when he arrives home.


How can you get a ghost to trust you?

Yes you can but it depends on the type of ghost . I have a ghost at my place doesn't talk but it howls . its a floating phantom face.


What was Hamlet's internal conflict?

Hamlet's father was king of Denmark before he died. Hamlet's uncle Claudius stepped in and married Hamlet's mother and became the De facto king, cutting out Hamlets rightful ascension to the throne. Hamlet had plenty of reason and motive to want Claudius dead, but to make things worse the ghost of Hamlet's father appears to him and informs him that it was Claudius who killed the king. Even though Hamlet is brought to see the ghost by his friend Horatio and two others who have also seen the ghost, it is, after all, a ghost story and Hamlet is rightfully wary of the information he received from a ghost. Swearing his friends to secrecy, he sets about investigating the truth in an attempt to prove his fathers murder before granting the command of his fathers ghost to exact revenge. Hamlet wants Claudius dead but wants him dead for the right reason and not blind ambition. He must feign madness and create distance between the ones he loves in order to accomplish his goals and increasingly his inability to make a decision and act upon it brings about intrigue and murder, and more murder, ending in a tragic blood bath where few survive. Hamlet could not decide whether it was right and just to kill Claudius and this indecision cost him the loss of the woman he loved, the loss of her father, the loss of her cousin, the loss of Hamlets mother and finally after discovering that he himself is dying from a poisoned tipped sword and that it was Claudius who commanded Tybalt to poison the sword Hamlet kills Claudius. People will say that Hamlet killed Claudius because his father the ghost told him to, but in truth, Hamlet killed Claudius with his last dying breath because it was Claudius that killed Hamlet. Sometimes it is better to make the wrong decision than make no decision at all.


Is there such thing as a ghost cat?

yes. trust me. yes.


Is blody Mary a ghost?

Bloody Mary is not a ghost. People want to fool you about it, so don't trust them.


Why is hamlet so concerned that horatio stay alive to tell his story?

The most important reason that Hamlet wants Horatio to tell everyone his story is that the only people who know that Claudius killed the former king are Hamlet, the Queen, and Horatio. Hamlet wants everyone in Denmark to know that Claudius was a murderer who obtained the crown through illegitimate means. Also, just before dying, Laertes (who had begun to have doubts about going through with the plan about halfway through the duel) begs for Hamlet's forgiveness and says that Claudius got what he deserved. Laertes says that if Hamlet forgives him for killing him, that he will forgive Hamlet for killing Polonius and him. Just after this, Laertes dies, and Hamlet forgives him. He seems to be fairly fond of Laertes and has a good amount of respect for him (for the most part) and wants everyone to know that Laertes was a good man and only Claudius should be held responsible for killing Hamlet and the Queen.


Is there an invincibility cheat for Ghost Recon on PS2?

no it does not work trust me.


How do you trust a boy who is in love with you?

You trust him like you would anyone you trust; don't second guess him when he tells you what he will do, how he feels, etc.