0
All of this scene is a speech by Hecate explaining why she is angry, as a lead up to a happy song and dance number. Basically like an over-controlling bureaucrat, she is mad at her subordinates for doing stuff without copying every single e-mail to her. Why does your teacher even care about this scene? Shakespeare didn't write it. Nobody ever performs it. Why not forget about it?
Wiki User
∙ 8y ago
Wiki User
∙ 13y agoIn Act 3, Scene 5, Hecate appears before the Witches and demands to know why she has been excluded from their meetings with Macbeth.
Wiki User
∙ 13y agoIn Act 3, Scene 5, Hecate appears before the Witches and demands to know why she has been excluded from their meetings with Macbeth.
Wiki User
∙ 13y agoIn Act 3, Scene 5, Hecate appears before the Witches and demands to know why she has been excluded from their meetings with Macbeth.
Wiki User
∙ 8y agoIn Act 3, Scene 5, Hecate appears before the Witches and demands to know why she has been excluded from their meetings with Macbeth.
Alexia Gonzalez
They ordered the deaths of both duncan and banquo
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why do you think critics are so sure that someone other than Shakespeare's wrote Hecate's speech?
There are a number of reasons. Hecate and the witches talk differently in the disputed scenes (Act 3 Scene 5 and parts of Act 4 Scene 1) from the way they do elsewhere (in 1,1 and 1,3). In Act 1 their speech is terse and mysterious. But Hecate talks like Titania from A Midsummer Night's Dream ("Upon the corner of the moon There hangs a vaporous drop profound; I'll catch it ere it come to ground" or "And now about the cauldron sing Like elves and fairies in a ring.") She is cutesy and silly, not threatening. There are references to two songs which the witches are to sing in the disputed scenes-- "Come away, come away", and "Black Spirits"--accompanied no doubt with a song-and-dance number. These songs are not by Shakespeare; they are from Thomas Middleton's play The Witch. And the speeches for Hecate sound like the characters in that play. Look it up if you like; the text still exists and is available online. And in addition, Hecate's plan revealed in her Act 3 Scene 5 speech is to control Macbeth by making him overconfident with an overconfidence potion, so he'll come a cropper. But such a development sucks all the interest out of the play: we are interested in what will happen to Macbeth and Lady Macbeth because of the guilt they feel over Duncan's murder. If Macbeth's behaviour is due to magical intervention none of that matters. So the reasons add up to this--this sounds like Middleton, not Shakespeare, and some of it is indisputably Middleton. It is inconsistent with the portrayal of the witches elsewhere and the structure of the play as a whole. And let's be honest: what director would want to have a song in the middle of the cauldron scene with the scintillating line "Titty, Tiffin, keep it stiff in."? The answer is, of course, none.
Who is the witch goddess in Macbeth?
There is no "goddess of which craft" in the play Macbeth. There are however 3 witches which appear early in the play as prophets who hail Macbeth, the general and prophesy his ascent to king hood.
Who said 'How did you dare To trade and traffic with Macbeth in riddles and affairs of death'?
Hecate supervised the supernatural beings in the Shakespearean play 'Macbeth'. But in Act 1 Scene 3, without Hecate's knowledge or consent, the three witches made their presence known to friends and fellow Generals Macbeth [c.1014-August 15, 1057] and Banquo. They even went so far as to advise Banquo and Macbeth of their future career moves. But Hecate caught up with her witchly employees by Act 3 Scene 5. She let them know that she knew what they'd been up to, and how she felt about that. So Hecate was the source of the since famous quotation, 'How did you dare/To trade and traffic with Macbeth/In riddles and affairs of death' [Lines 3-5].
What is the conversation is between Romeo and Juliet?
Romeo and Juliet hold conversations in Act I Scene 5, Act II Scene 2, Act II Scene 6 and Act III Scene 5.
How many acts in Romeo and Juliet?
There is : Act 1 scene 1 Act 1 scene 2 Act 1 scene 3 Act 1 scene 4 Act 1 scene 5 Act 2 scene 1 Act 2 scene 2 Act 2 scene 3 Act 2 scene 4 Act 2 scene 5 Act 2 scene 6 Act 3 scene 1 Act 3 scene 2 Act 3 scene 3 Act 3 scene 4 Act 3 scene 5 Act 4 scene 1 Act 4 scene 2 Act 4 scene 3 Act 4 scene 4 Act 4 scene 5 Act 5 scene 1 Act 5 scene 2 Act 5 scene 3 x meikaah
Why is Hecate angry with the three witches with 2 reasons?
Hecate is angry with the three witches because they have been meddling in Macbeth's affairs without her approval, which has caused chaos and confusion. Additionally, their actions have disrupted the natural order of things and could potentially lead to their own downfall.
How many syllables are in the line Have I not reason beldams as you are said by Hecate in Act III scene v?
Ten of them.
Is Macbeth who is the leader of the witches?
Hecate is the leader of the witches in the play "Macbeth" by William Shakespeare (Baptized April 26, 1564 - April 23, 1616).Specifically, Hecate does not appear until Act 3 Scene 5. She meets with the three witches who appear in the play's opening scene. Hecate chides them for making and carrying out plans regarding Macbeth without consulting her first.
What does Hamlet's speech to the players mean?
The speech that Hamlet gives to the players means don't over act. The speech is given in Act 3 Scene 2 of the play.
What is Capulet's reaction to his daughter in act 4 scene 2?
he is very angry with her and throws her out.
What is the main point of Capulet's speech in scene 3?
In Capulet's speech in Act 3, Scene 3 of Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet," the main point is that he is initially angry with Juliet for refusing to marry Paris. However, he later changes his mind and decides to support Juliet's decision, telling her that she must now marry Romeo instead.
Which excerpt from Hecates speech in scene 5 foreshadows macbeths downfall in this tragedy?
In Act 3, Scene 5 of "Macbeth," Hecate foreshadows Macbeth's downfall by warning that he should be “charmed by fairness,” indicating that appearances can be deceptive and that he will be led astray by false promises. This suggests that Macbeth's overconfidence and blind trust in others will ultimately contribute to his downfall.
What scene does Shylock give that big speech on how Christians and Jews are alike in Shakespeare's play 'The Merchant of Venice'?
Scene 1, Act 3.
What scene was Caesar killed in Julius Caesar?
In Shakespeare's play Julius Caesar, the murder of Caesar takes place in Act III Scene i. Act III Scene ii is the scene containing Caesar's funeral and Antony's famous speech, "Friends, Romans, Countrymen"
Why do you think critics are so sure that someone other than Shakespeare's wrote Hecate's speech?
There are a number of reasons. Hecate and the witches talk differently in the disputed scenes (Act 3 Scene 5 and parts of Act 4 Scene 1) from the way they do elsewhere (in 1,1 and 1,3). In Act 1 their speech is terse and mysterious. But Hecate talks like Titania from A Midsummer Night's Dream ("Upon the corner of the moon There hangs a vaporous drop profound; I'll catch it ere it come to ground" or "And now about the cauldron sing Like elves and fairies in a ring.") She is cutesy and silly, not threatening. There are references to two songs which the witches are to sing in the disputed scenes-- "Come away, come away", and "Black Spirits"--accompanied no doubt with a song-and-dance number. These songs are not by Shakespeare; they are from Thomas Middleton's play The Witch. And the speeches for Hecate sound like the characters in that play. Look it up if you like; the text still exists and is available online. And in addition, Hecate's plan revealed in her Act 3 Scene 5 speech is to control Macbeth by making him overconfident with an overconfidence potion, so he'll come a cropper. But such a development sucks all the interest out of the play: we are interested in what will happen to Macbeth and Lady Macbeth because of the guilt they feel over Duncan's murder. If Macbeth's behaviour is due to magical intervention none of that matters. So the reasons add up to this--this sounds like Middleton, not Shakespeare, and some of it is indisputably Middleton. It is inconsistent with the portrayal of the witches elsewhere and the structure of the play as a whole. And let's be honest: what director would want to have a song in the middle of the cauldron scene with the scintillating line "Titty, Tiffin, keep it stiff in."? The answer is, of course, none.
What is Romeo and Juliet Lady Capulet speech Act 1 Scene 3 context?
Act 1 Scene 3 is all about broaching to Juliet the possibility of marrying Paris. Anything Mrs. Capulet says in that scene is to be taken in that context.
Who is the witch goddess in Macbeth?
There is no "goddess of which craft" in the play Macbeth. There are however 3 witches which appear early in the play as prophets who hail Macbeth, the general and prophesy his ascent to king hood.
