answersLogoWhite

0

Plato's understanding that the soul has three parts is at least an initially fruitful way to begin to think about human nature. The context of his discussion is important. He is thinking of a well-ordered Republic that is a harmony of three different classes of people in which each class has its own function. This is supposed to be like a well-ordered soul that is a harmony of three different functions.

One part has appetites, desires, cravings, or impulses. Another part has reason or conceptual thinking. The third (spirited) part is really an in-between part that can receive commands from reason and control the desires.

We do learn analogically, in other words, by comparing similarities and differences. The only way to evaluate whether or not an analogy is good is to think it through by comparing the qualities of the two supposedly similar objects. This thinking can be fruitful even if one ultimately rejects an analogy.

This is why Plato's view of the tripartite soul is, minimally, a good starting point for thinking about the nature of being human. Presumably, he wanted us to think it through for ourselves. Also, it is obviously a richer understanding than any view of human nature that would be less complex.

It does seem that it's correct that we have desires, that we are able to think conceptually, and that we are able to control our desires. That does make this view initially plausible.

On the other hand, it does not answer two other important questions. First, is there some additional essential aspect of human nature? Many thinkers have argued in various ways that there is. Second, what is the soul itself? Which object has these supposedly essential qualities? In particular, is it something capable of change or not? Plato suggests in some dialogues that it is capable of change, which means that it is a continuant (something that exists through time).

If so, what is it? Once it is separated in thought from its qualities, how could one even think about it? On the other hand, perhaps upon serious examination it turns out to be wholly empty. This fundamental ontological problem is one that doesn't just apply to human beings; it applies to understanding the nature of all individuals.

Without clear answers to these questions, Plato's understanding of the tripartite soul is implausible as it stands. In other words, whether one finds Plato's view congenial depends upon one's own understanding of human nature.

If Plato stimulates us to think harder about human nature, Plato would be pleased.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

What else can I help you with?

Continue Learning about Philosophy

What are some questions about human nature that have intrigued philosophers and scientists for centuries?

Questions about human nature that have intrigued philosophers and scientists for centuries include: What is the essence of human nature? Are humans inherently good or evil? What drives human behavior? How do nature and nurture influence human development?


What was platos understanding of self?

Plato believed that the self consists of three parts: reason, spirit, and appetite, each representing different aspects of human nature. He thought that the goal of life is to achieve harmony among these parts through virtue and self-control. Additionally, Plato believed in the immortality of the soul and that true knowledge comes from introspection and contemplation.


What is a lesson about human nature called?

A lesson about human nature is often referred to as a moral or philosophical insight. It can also be called a reflection on the essence of human behavior or characteristics.


What parts of life nature or human nature do you control?

I am a machine learning model programmed to provide information and assistance based on the input I receive. I do not have the ability to control any parts of life, nature, or human nature.


What is the integrated view of human nature?

The integrated view of human nature is the belief that humans are a complex combination of biological, psychological, social, and spiritual dimensions. This perspective emphasizes the interconnectedness of these aspects in shaping human behavior and experiences. Understanding and addressing all these dimensions is essential for a comprehensive understanding of human nature.

Related Questions

What is the significance of the tripartite nature of man, encompassing the body, soul, and spirit, in understanding human existence and spirituality?

The tripartite nature of man, consisting of the body, soul, and spirit, is significant in understanding human existence and spirituality because it acknowledges the complexity of human beings. The body represents the physical aspect, the soul represents the emotional and mental aspect, and the spirit represents the connection to something greater than oneself. Recognizing and balancing these three aspects can lead to a deeper understanding of oneself and a more holistic approach to spirituality.


When was Human Nature - Human Nature album - created?

Human Nature - Human Nature album - was created on 2000-12-01.


What is the Ancient Alien or Astronaut theory is it be plausible?

It hypothesizes that aliens have been visiting and shaping human civilization for thousands of years. It is not a plausible theory and is certainly not accepted in science.


How is nature paralleling human condition?

you know already that human condition is a part of nature human is nature


What is human nature in Welsh?

Mae hynny'n naturiol.(That is human nature.)


Can an animal change its nature to human nature?

i think that we were not at all any monkeys so animals can not change there nature to human nature


When was On Human Nature created?

On Human Nature was created on 2004-10-18.


When was A Treatise of Human Nature created?

A Treatise of Human Nature was created in 1740.


What is human nature ethics?

Human nature ethics is a form of ethical theory that relies on examining human nature in order to come to ethical conclusions. Often human nature ethical theorists base their ethics on biological drives.


What is tripertite personality?

Tripartite personality is a theory that Sigmund Freud thought of. Freud thought the human pschye had three parts to it, hence the name tripartite. These parts are called the id, ego, and superego.


What is the nature and scop of Human resource management?

nature and scope of Human resource management?"


How human is dependence on nature?

please let me have a write-up on Human dependence on Nature