answersLogoWhite

0

Crito says to do what people think is right, but Socrates says you must do what you think is right.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago

What else can I help you with?

Continue Learning about Philosophy

How does critos's propsal go against Socrates teaching that the unexamined life is not worth living?

The dialogue begins with Socrates waking up to the presence of Crito in his prison cell. When Socrates expresses surprise that the guard has let him in at such an early hour, Crito informs Socrates that he knows the guard well and has done him a certain benefaction.Crito has bad news for Socrates. He tells him that there are eyewitness reports that the ship has come in from Delos, and that tomorrow Socrates will be executed. Socrates rebuffs the report, saying he has had a dream - a vision of a woman in a white cloak telling him that on the third day hence he will go to Phthia, which is a reference to Achilles' threat in the Iliad that he-the mightiest of Greek warriors-might just leave for his home in "fertile" Phthia and be there in "just three days" if the Greeks fail to show him due respect. Socrates says that the meaning of this is perfectly clear - it will be three days until he dies.Crito does not allow Socrates to elaborate the meaning of the dream, but only calls him daimonic; Crito has arrived at this early hour to save Socrates from death. Crito tells Socrates that if he follows through with the execution, people will assume that Crito and friends were too cheap to finance an escape. Crito insists that he will not get into much trouble as a result of having helped Socrates escape, for those who would inform against him are cheaply bought. He adds that if Socrates is afraid of depleting Crito's account, there are foreigners (xenoi), Simmias and Cebes, who have come to town with money. Moreover, Crito urges, Socrates has support in other cities, including Thessaly, and to be exiled would not be entirely negative.Crito continues with moral appeals. He says that Socrates would be unjustly joining the efforts of his enemies against him. He is choosing the "easiest path" as opposed to the courageous, honorable, and virtuous path, which Crito feels is to flee from certain, unjust death. Socrates would be acting cowardly if he weren't to resist such injustices.Crito further argues that a father (like Socrates) has an obligation to nurture and educate his children and should avoid orphaning them if at all possible. He tells Socrates that if his sons do not meet with the usual fate of orphans, it will be no thanks to him. Crito adds that the trial should never have taken place and might have been managed differently. He says that the failure to escape will be a ridiculous climax to the whole affair and would be attributed to the shameful cowardice of Socrates' friends (45d,e).


Related Questions

When socrates compares critos opinion to his own he is using?

dialectic.


How does critos's propsal go against Socrates teaching that the unexamined life is not worth living?

The dialogue begins with Socrates waking up to the presence of Crito in his prison cell. When Socrates expresses surprise that the guard has let him in at such an early hour, Crito informs Socrates that he knows the guard well and has done him a certain benefaction.Crito has bad news for Socrates. He tells him that there are eyewitness reports that the ship has come in from Delos, and that tomorrow Socrates will be executed. Socrates rebuffs the report, saying he has had a dream - a vision of a woman in a white cloak telling him that on the third day hence he will go to Phthia, which is a reference to Achilles' threat in the Iliad that he-the mightiest of Greek warriors-might just leave for his home in "fertile" Phthia and be there in "just three days" if the Greeks fail to show him due respect. Socrates says that the meaning of this is perfectly clear - it will be three days until he dies.Crito does not allow Socrates to elaborate the meaning of the dream, but only calls him daimonic; Crito has arrived at this early hour to save Socrates from death. Crito tells Socrates that if he follows through with the execution, people will assume that Crito and friends were too cheap to finance an escape. Crito insists that he will not get into much trouble as a result of having helped Socrates escape, for those who would inform against him are cheaply bought. He adds that if Socrates is afraid of depleting Crito's account, there are foreigners (xenoi), Simmias and Cebes, who have come to town with money. Moreover, Crito urges, Socrates has support in other cities, including Thessaly, and to be exiled would not be entirely negative.Crito continues with moral appeals. He says that Socrates would be unjustly joining the efforts of his enemies against him. He is choosing the "easiest path" as opposed to the courageous, honorable, and virtuous path, which Crito feels is to flee from certain, unjust death. Socrates would be acting cowardly if he weren't to resist such injustices.Crito further argues that a father (like Socrates) has an obligation to nurture and educate his children and should avoid orphaning them if at all possible. He tells Socrates that if his sons do not meet with the usual fate of orphans, it will be no thanks to him. Crito adds that the trial should never have taken place and might have been managed differently. He says that the failure to escape will be a ridiculous climax to the whole affair and would be attributed to the shameful cowardice of Socrates' friends (45d,e).


Trending Questions
What does this Confucius saying mean look at the means which a man employs consider his motives observe his pleasures A man simply cannot conceal himself? Can you consume coffee grounds for an energy boost? Why does my eye twitch whenever I eat a banana? How does the passionate tone adopted by Satanta within the speech your Heart is Bursting most help him achieve his purpose? What is your opinion on the statement "I like your Christ but not your Christianity"? What are the top ten hardest board exams in the Philippines? How are philosophy and psychology related? What character flaw does the hero Odysseus reveal by refusing to leave the cave? How can emotional appeals, such as personal anecdotes and heartwarming stories, be effectively used to persuade an audience? What is a statement that has only a semicolon standing alone? How can baby teeth stem cells be utilized for potential medical treatments or therapies in the future? According to aristotle what was the best form of government? What is an example of a metaphor in Old Major's speech? What are the steps in applying critical thinking skills to a particular problem.? What step do you take after you have researched your essay? Is sound a boon or bane? Which step would you take when organizing your essay details specially? What is the most effective self-defense technique to use in a dangerous situation, such as a karate chop to the neck? Examples of understatements in A Modest Proposal? What is the philosophy of time?