answersLogoWhite

0

Circe counsels Odysseus against engaging Scylla in battle because Scylla is a terrifying sea monster with multiple heads that could prove too difficult to defeat without sustaining heavy casualties. Circe advises Odysseus to choose the lesser of two evils by avoiding a direct confrontation with Scylla, as losing some of his men to her would be better than risking the entire crew in a futile battle.

User Avatar

AnswerBot

1y ago

What else can I help you with?

Continue Learning about Philosophy

What does Circe think when Odysseus asks how he can fight off Scylla?

Circe warns Odysseus that Scylla is too powerful to fight directly. She advises him to sail quickly past her, sacrificing a few of his men to her instead of engaging in a battle he cannot win.


How does Odysseus use intelligence with his encounter with Scylla?

He shows intelligence by listenng to circe and not trying to fight either of the monsters, but staying closer to scylla because charybdis can take the hole ship while scylla can only take 6 men at a time."In Homer's Odyssey XII, Odysseus is given advice by Circe to sail closer to Scylla, for Charybdis could drown his whole ship: "Hug Scylla's crag-sail on past her-top speed! Better by far to lose six men and keep your ship than lose your entire crew"[6] she warns, and tells Odysseus to bid Scylla's mother, the river nymph Crataeis, to prevent her from pouncing more than once. Odysseus then successfully sails his ship past Scylla and Charybdis, but Scylla manages to catch six of his men, devouring them alive." (Wikipedia).


What good did it do Odysseus to arm himself for a battle with scylla?

Arming himself for battle with Scylla provided Odysseus with at least a chance to defend himself and his crew against the monster. While he couldn't defeat Scylla, being armed allowed him to make the best of a difficult situation and focus on minimizing casualties.


Which of the two Scylla or Charybdis was the lesser of two evils why?

Scylla was considered the lesser of two evils compared to Charybdis. Scylla was a six-headed sea monster that posed a physical threat to sailors, while Charybdis was a whirlpool that could devour entire ships. Navigating through Scylla's six heads may have been safer, as it was possible to lose only a few crew members, whereas Charybdis could easily destroy an entire ship.


Are Charybdis and Scylla friends?

In Greek mythology, Charybdis and Scylla are not friends; in fact, they are adversaries. They are two sea monsters who are often depicted as being in close proximity to each other, creating a dangerous passage for ships to navigate. Sailors had to choose between facing Charybdis' powerful whirlpool or Scylla's deadly rock formations.

Related Questions

Who of the following work against Odysseus Athena Helios Poseidon Tiresias Scylla?

Poseidon and Scylla work against Odysseus in "The Odyssey." Poseidon holds a grudge against Odysseus for blinding his son, Polyphemus, while Scylla is a sea monster that attacks Odysseus's men as they sail past her lair.


Is scylla real?

No, Scylla is not real. Scylla is a mythological demon in the Odyssey who was once a beautiful naiad, (sea nymph) and Poseidon was attracted to her and so Poseidon's wife found out and turned the naiad into Scylla. This information is in the book The Odyssey, you should read it


What is the name of scylla's myth?

The name of the myth which featured Scylla was the Odyssey allegedly written by Homer


What was the name of the 6 headed monster in the odyssey?

Scylla.


How many of Odysseus men did scylla get?

According to Homer's Odyssey, six of Odysseus' men were eaten alive by Scylla.


Where does it talk about Scylla and Charybdis in the Odyssey?

in the part where Odyseus is sailing in between them


What are some mythologic water creatures that are evil?

For instance Scylla and Charybdis, in the Odyssey.


What is the name of the creature that has six heads and twelve legs in the odyssey?

Her name is Scylla


Is Scylla a female monster In the Odyssey?

Yes, Scylla is a female sea monster in Homer's "Odyssey." She is described as having the upper body of a woman and a lower body made up of several dog-like sea creatures. Scylla posed a deadly threat to Odysseus and his crew as they navigated through her territory.


Did Scylla devour six crew members in the Odyssey?

Yes, in the Odyssey, Scylla is described as a sea monster with six heads that devours six crew members from Odysseus's ship as they pass by her lair. Odysseus was unable to save them despite his efforts.


Who is Scylla in The Odyssey?

Scylla: sea monster of gray rockScylla was a six-headed monster in The Odyssey. She lived on a promontory and would eat six men (one for every head) from all the ships that passed by. She is considered a threshold guardian.Scylla, partnered in a strait of water with Charybdis, is a creature with 12 arms, and 6 heads, each with 3 rows of teeth. Whenever a boat passes by, Scylla takes at least 6 men to eat; one for each head.You can find Scylla and Charybdis in "The Odyssey" by Homer, Book XIIScylla was originally aid to be a water nymph, with whom the god Glaucus was enamoured. Scylla was transformed into a monster by Circe, whom fell in love with Glaucus but could not win him over.


Did Odysseus kill scylla?

Yes, in Homer's "The Odyssey," Odysseus and his crew encounter the monster Scylla while trying to navigate through a treacherous strait. Scylla kills several of Odysseus's men, but Odysseus is unable to kill her as she is a powerful and immortal monster.