answersLogoWhite

0

The first question is "Is there property in the state of nature?". Not all philosophers agree. Such a "right to property" is absent in Hobbes but it is asserted by john Locke. The latter defined the original aquisition of property as the mingling of labor with natural things which results in the production of a good. Locke, said that every person has herself as property: you own yourself by nature. By producing a good through labor you also own that good. This is so for Locke even in the state of nature. To your question why is property (in the Lockean sense) not protected in the state of nature, there is a simple answer: who is there to protect it? All you have is yourself and whatever forces you can muster up. But there is no police, courts or legal system to protect property rights.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago

What else can I help you with?

Continue Learning about Philosophy

Why do we enter the social contract for Locke?

According to Locke, individuals enter the social contract to protect their natural rights, such as life, liberty, and property. By forming a government and agreeing to abide by its rules, individuals can ensure their rights are protected and avoid the state of nature's chaos and conflict.


How do hobs and Locke and Rousseau understand the state of nature diffrently?

Hobbes believed that the state of nature was a condition of constant war and conflict, where life was "nasty, brutish, and short." Locke saw the state of nature as characterized by natural rights and cooperation, with individuals having the right to life, liberty, and property. Rousseau viewed the state of nature as a peaceful and egalitarian state, only corrupted by the development of society and civilization.


Describes a major difference between the Enlightenment thinkers Thomas Hobbes and John Locke?

One major difference between Hobbes and Locke is their views on the state of nature. Hobbes believed that the state of nature was a state of war and chaos, where life was solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short. In contrast, Locke believed that the state of nature was characterized by peace, equality, and natural rights, such as life, liberty, and property.


What statement of Thomas Hobbes and john Locke is not true?

It would be inaccurate to claim that Thomas Hobbes believed individuals in a state of nature lived a peaceful and harmonious existence, as he famously argued that such a state would be characterized by a constant state of war due to human nature. Similarly, it would be incorrect to attribute the belief to John Locke that property rights are absolute and unlimited, as he argued that property rights are only valid as long as they do not harm others or waste resources.


What did john Locke believe about State of nature?

John Locke believed that in the "state of nature," individuals are inherently free and equal, possessing natural rights to life, liberty, and property. He argued that the purpose of government is to protect these rights and that if a government fails to do so, individuals have the right to rebel and establish a new government.

Related Questions

A father and daughter own a property the deed is in their names under joint tenants the daughter is separating from her spouse whos name is not on the deed can the husband force sale of the house?

The answer may depend on whether you live in a community property state. If so, the property may be protected if it was purchased using funds acquired prior to the marriage or by inheritance. However, this is a complicated issue and you need to consult with an attorney who can review your situation under your state laws.In a separate property state the property held in a joint tenancy would be protected in most cases.The answer may depend on whether you live in a community property state. If so, the property may be protected if it was purchased using funds acquired prior to the marriage or by inheritance. However, this is a complicated issue and you need to consult with an attorney who can review your situation under your state laws.In a separate property state the property held in a joint tenancy would be protected in most cases.The answer may depend on whether you live in a community property state. If so, the property may be protected if it was purchased using funds acquired prior to the marriage or by inheritance. However, this is a complicated issue and you need to consult with an attorney who can review your situation under your state laws.In a separate property state the property held in a joint tenancy would be protected in most cases.The answer may depend on whether you live in a community property state. If so, the property may be protected if it was purchased using funds acquired prior to the marriage or by inheritance. However, this is a complicated issue and you need to consult with an attorney who can review your situation under your state laws.In a separate property state the property held in a joint tenancy would be protected in most cases.


Compare and contrast state of nature according Hobbes and rousseu?

According to Thomas Hobbes, the state of nature or life would be worthless if not protected by the state, while according to Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the state of nature involves men driving towards self-preservation.


What property interests are protected by substantive due process?

The property interest protected by substantive due process is the deprivation of property.


If you are divorced with joint property and she is filing bankruptcy in another state will they take your property?

It depends upon how the property is titled and the type of property. If it is a home that is used as the primary residence it will probably be protected by the state homestead exemption. Other real property is at risk if it is Joint Tenancy a lesser risk if it is Tenancy-in-Common.


Is a primary residence protected from Medicaid?

Homestead property is not a bar to receiving Medicaid. However, the State may file a lien on the property, payable when it is sold or otherwise transferred.


Is my deceased spouse's debt my responsibility?

That depends on the nature of the debt and the laws in your jurisdiction. In a separate property state a person's estate is responsible for paying their debts. However, jointly owned property is usually protected from the debts of one spouse. Debts by one spouse need to be examined, for example, to determine if the goods or services benefitted both spouses. In a community property state the surviving spouse is generally responsible since marital property and debts are shared. You need to consult with an attorney in your jurisdiction.


Why is the title to real property permanent whereas some intellectual property is limited in the time that it is protected?

Why is the title to real property permanent whereas some intellectual property is limited in the time that it is protected?


Why do we enter the social contract for Locke?

According to Locke, individuals enter the social contract to protect their natural rights, such as life, liberty, and property. By forming a government and agreeing to abide by its rules, individuals can ensure their rights are protected and avoid the state of nature's chaos and conflict.


How did Public property are better protected by observation of national ethics discuss?

how did public property are better protected by observation of national ethics.


What happens to your property when you go to jail?

When you go to jail, your property is typically secured and managed by a trusted individual, such as a family member or friend, or by the state. This is to ensure that your belongings are protected and can be returned to you upon your release.


How do hobs and Locke and Rousseau understand the state of nature diffrently?

Hobbes believed that the state of nature was a condition of constant war and conflict, where life was "nasty, brutish, and short." Locke saw the state of nature as characterized by natural rights and cooperation, with individuals having the right to life, liberty, and property. Rousseau viewed the state of nature as a peaceful and egalitarian state, only corrupted by the development of society and civilization.


Are flags copyrighted and protected by intellectual property laws?

Yes, flags can be copyrighted and protected by intellectual property laws, depending on the country and specific circumstances.