answersLogoWhite

0

In an experiment conducted over 100 years ago, a Dr. DuncanMacDougall placed a dying patient upon a scale and recorded changes in his weight during the dying process. At the moment of death, the weight of the patient dropped by approximately 21 grams (.75 oz). This led the physician to conclude that the human soul must have weight since evaporation of sweat and other bodily excretions seemed to have been ruled out.

However, in order to accept the results of an experiment, that experiment must have repeatability. That is, someone else must be able to independently perform the same experiment and get the same results. This experiment has neither been repeated nor confirmed by anyone except for Dr. MacDougall and his assistant. Therefore the idea that the human soul has a precisely measurable and constant weight is not a logically acceptable idea.

So the short answer to your question is no.

User Avatar

Wiki User

∙ 17y ago
User Avatar

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

In the movie 21 grams what does the 21 grams account for?

I think 21 grams refers to the weight of a human soul.


Is there any modern research to show the weight of the soul?

Some believe the soul weighs 21 grams, due to experiments in weighing a person just before and immediately after death, when the body becomes lighter by 21 grams.


In the movie 7 grams what does the 7 grams refer to?

In the movie "21 Grams," the title refers to the popular belief that the human soul weighs 21 grams, based on a study by physician Duncan MacDougall in the early 20th century. The film explores themes of interconnectedness, fate, and the impact of loss on the characters' lives.


Do you really lose 21 grams when you die?

No, i dont think you lose 21 grams of weight when you die. a scientist made an experiment, attempting to figure it out. the very first time he tested it out, the weight of the persons was 21 grams diffrent. in later attempts, with other persons, it was not.


What does a tattoo of the number 21 symbolize?

The number 21 can symbolize a lot of things, it has a lot of different backgrounds but to me the most interesting and important thing about 21 (which is why I've gotten a tattoo of it) is 21 grams is the weight of the soul. I also love that if you double 21 you get the answer to the universe (Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy).


How much is 21 grams of silver?

The value of 21 grams of silver will vary depending on the current market price of silver. You can multiply the weight in grams (21) by the current price of silver per gram to get the value.


What is the weight of soul?

It varies, actually. When sad and down-trodden, it is heavy and over-bearing. But, when it is happy and elated, it creates a light-hearted spirit and uplifting experience.


What Sean Penn movie was named for the mass that a person supposedly loses when they die?

because apperently when you pass away, your body weighs 21 grams less because your soul weighs 21 grams, ...


What household item weighs 21 grams?

A U.S. nickel weighs 5 grams, so you would need four nickels to equal 20 grams. Therefore, a U.S. nickel would be the closest household item in weight to 21 grams.


Average weight of a class ring?

The average weight of a class ring is around 10-20 grams, depending on the size and design. They are typically made of materials such as gold, silver, or stainless steel, which contribute to their weight.


When was 21 Grams released?

21 Grams was released on 11/21/2003.


How many oz is 21 grams?

21 ounces = 595.34 grams.

Trending Questions
What direction do waves travel? Does a sea breeze have low or high air pressure? In order for heat to be transferred by conduction which of the following must occur A cold object must be heated with hot air. A hot object must be directly touching a cold object. The Sun must heat t? What is the velocity equation? How does does solar radiation and infrared radiation interact with earth? What is 0.002kL to liters? Which object is used to focus light in a light microscope? Why can liquid water store more heat energy than an equal amount of any other naturally occurring substance? What is bernoulli's princeiple? What is the relationship between the fluorescent light emission spectrum and the color produced by a fluorescent light source? When A child throws a ball up in the air to a height of 3.5 m and catches it at the same point from which he threw it. The ball is in the air for a total of 1.7 seconds. What is the average velocity? What low property of ice allows it to float on water? What is the benefit of infra red ray? What is the value of gravitational constant G? How does taking a cold shower conserve energy? What sources of error would account for differences in measurement of the same thing? Can you compare and contrast nuclear energy use in the US and France? The microwaves used to heat food have a wavelenght of 125m what is the enegry of one photon of the microwave radiation? Why do front load washer vibrates excessively? What is an example of average acceleration?