How do you know if your poetry is any good?

Answer 1

Poetry is designed to provoke emotion. Good poetry will cause the reader or listener to feel emotion - really good poetry will cause them to feel strong emotion.

First, check your poem for the basics: correct format, spelling, grammar, rhyme scheme, rhythm, and everything else that makes it a poem instead of an essay (although a poem does not have to rhyme but it does have to have a good sense of rhythm). Next, edit it down to the most concise form that you can, so that each phrase is the best that you can possibly write. Make sure that each line evokes a vivid mental image, a powerful sense, and/or a strong emotion.

You can let other people read your poetry if you'd like, before you get the final form completed. I advise that you pick people who understand poetry and will give you an honest and objective opinion. You usually don't want to use your friends or relatives for this, because they will have a tendency to say "oh, it's great!" without really understanding, or they won't want to "hurt your feelings" by saying anything negative. You want honest criticism, so if you use a proof-reader, pick another poet.

Two men can play Taps, but only one will make you cry...

Answer 2

One way to gauge the quality of your poetry is to seek feedback from others, such as friends, family, or writing groups. Another way is to compare your work to established poets in the genre you're writing in, and see if your writing exhibits similar techniques and depth. Ultimately, trust your own instincts and continued effort in refining your craft.