answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

ICD 10. It has two different criteria. Clinical criteria are qualitative and picture-fitting. Research criteria are quantitative and menu-driven.

DSM-IV has only menu driven criteria. Thus inter-rater reliability for DSM-IV diagnoses are poor due to poor adherence to quantitative criteria in actual practice.

ICD 10 encourages selection of one diagnosis, whereas DSM-IV allows selection of as many diagnoses as fit the criteria.

Diagnostic categorical differences.

In DSM IV, schizophrenic symptoms are required to be present for six months unless florid, whereas in ICD 10 it is only 1 month.

IN DSM IV conversion and dissociative disorders are distinguished, not in ICD 10.

In DSM IV there are two types of anorexia (binging and non), and two types of bulimia (purging and non), whereas in ICD 10 there is simply anorexia, bulimia, and undefined atypical forms.

Axial Systems

IN ICD 10 the axial system is as follows:

AXIS I: Clinical psychiatric syndromes

AXIS II: Specific disorders of development

AXIS III: Intellectual level

AXIS IV: Associated medical conditions

AXIS V: Associated abnormal psychosocial conditions

AXIS VI: Global Social Functioning

Note that in ICD 10, AXIS I includes pschiatric disorders, personality disorders, and mental retardation, but not disability.

In ICD 10, Axis II is similar to DSM IV Axis V, Global Assessment of Function... (I don't think it could be any more confusing than this!)

In DSM IV, the axial system is like this:

AXIS 1: Clinical psychiatric disorders

AXIS II: Personality disorders, mental retardation, maladaptive personality.behavior

AXIS III: General medical disorders.

AXIS IV: PSychosocial/envrionmental stressors.

AXIS V: Global Assessment of Function.

Note that in DSM-IV, autism is AXIS 1, substance abuse is AXIS 1, OCD is AXIS I but OCPD is AXIS II.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

AnswerBot

2w ago

The DSM-IV-TR is an updated version of the DSM-IV that includes text revisions and additional information. Both versions use the same diagnostic criteria, but the DSM-IV-TR provides more detailed descriptions and clarifications for some disorders. The DSM-IV-TR also includes new disorders and changes to existing diagnostic criteria based on updated research and clinical experience.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What are the similarities and differences between dsm iv and dsm iv tr?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Psychology

What are the similarities and differences between dsm iv and dsm v?

The DSM-IV and DSM-V are both classification systems used to diagnose mental health disorders. One key difference is that the DSM-V includes dimensional assessments for some disorders, while the DSM-IV relied solely on categorical diagnoses. Another difference is the structure of the two manuals, with the DSM-V organizing disorders based on shared features and etiology, while the DSM-IV used a multiaxial system.


What is the most current edition-dsm iv or dsm iv-tr?

The DSM IV Diagnostic manual was first published in 1994. The DSM IV - TR is a text revision published in 2000. So the most current edition is indeed the DSM IV - TR. The DSM V is due in 2012 and may be very different from the current style. See http://www.psych.org/mainmenu/research/dsmiv/dsmivtr.aspx for more info.


In the dsm IV what is a midnight personality?

In the DSM-IV, there is no specific diagnosis or category known as a "midnight personality." It could be a colloquial or nonclinical term that is not recognized within the diagnostic criteria of the DSM-IV.


Is there a dsm iv for anger problems?

The DSM-IV does include diagnostic criteria for various mental health disorders, including those related to anger such as Intermittent Explosive Disorder. However, the DSM-IV has been replaced by the DSM-5 which provides updated criteria for diagnosing mental health conditions, including anger-related disorders.


What is the DSM-IV?

The DSM-IV (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition) is a manual published by the American Psychiatric Association that provides a standardized classification of mental disorders. It is used by clinicians and researchers to diagnose and classify mental health conditions based on specific criteria and symptoms. The DSM-IV has been updated and replaced by the DSM-5.

Related questions

Similarities between DSM-IV-TR and ICD-10 classification of mental disorders?

what sim and difference between dsm and icd


What are the similarities and differences between dsm iv and dsm v?

The DSM-IV and DSM-V are both classification systems used to diagnose mental health disorders. One key difference is that the DSM-V includes dimensional assessments for some disorders, while the DSM-IV relied solely on categorical diagnoses. Another difference is the structure of the two manuals, with the DSM-V organizing disorders based on shared features and etiology, while the DSM-IV used a multiaxial system.


Who is the author of DSM-IV?

The DSM-IV is written and revised by the American Psychiatric Association.


How many pages are in the DSM-IV?

The DSM-IV has around 900 pages in total.


What is the most current edition-dsm iv or dsm iv-tr?

The DSM IV Diagnostic manual was first published in 1994. The DSM IV - TR is a text revision published in 2000. So the most current edition is indeed the DSM IV - TR. The DSM V is due in 2012 and may be very different from the current style. See http://www.psych.org/mainmenu/research/dsmiv/dsmivtr.aspx for more info.


What problems in earlier classification systems have the axes in the DSM-IV overcome?

The axes in the DSM-IV helped to address the limitations of earlier classification systems by incorporating a multidimensional approach to diagnosis. This allowed for a comprehensive understanding of an individual's mental health, taking into account both clinical disorders and psychosocial factors. Additionally, the inclusion of separate axes for different aspects of diagnosis promoted a more systematic and structured approach to assessment and treatment planning.


What is the catalog of disorders used to diagnose individuals?

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders - apex


What is the DSM IV code for psoriasis?

psoriasis


What DSM IV axis is Enuresis on?

Axis I


What is the DSM IV code for traumatic brain injury?

What is the dsm code for traumatic brain injury


What is the difference between DSM-IV for alcohol abuse and dependence and substance abuse and dependence?

Simply the substance used.


How does demonmocker simplify the dsm iv by saying anything jehovahs witnesses say is wrong is also what dsm iv says is wrong?

By typing, and yes probably