answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Some psychologists broke with Freud because they disagreed with his heavy emphasis on unconscious conflicts and sexuality as the primary drivers of behavior. They also criticized his lack of empirical evidence and the heavy reliance on clinical observations. Additionally, Freud's theories were seen as too deterministic and pessimistic by those who believed in more humanistic and positive approaches to psychology.

User Avatar

AnswerBot

10h ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why did some Psychologists break with freud?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Psychology

What does freud say about the mind that other psychologists disagree with?

One key aspect of Freud's theory that has faced criticism is his emphasis on the unconscious mind and the influence of early childhood experiences on adult behavior. Some psychologists view his ideas as overly deterministic and question the empirical evidence supporting his concepts of the id, ego, and superego. Additionally, Freud's focus on sexual and aggressive drives as primary motivators of behavior has been challenged by contemporary psychologists who emphasize a broader array of factors shaping human behavior.


Which of Sigmund Freud ideas would not be accepted by most contemporary psychologists?

One idea of Sigmund Freud's that is not widely accepted by contemporary psychologists is his emphasis on the role of unconscious sexual and aggressive instincts (psychosexual theory) in shaping personality development. Many contemporary psychologists focus more on cognitive and social factors in understanding personality rather than Freud's emphasis on sexual and aggressive drives.


Who is not one of the notable psychologists that contributed to your knowledge on learning?

One notable psychologist who did not contribute to my knowledge on learning is Sigmund Freud. Freud focused more on psychoanalysis and the unconscious mind, rather than learning theory.


How plausible do you think Freud's ideas are?

Freud's ideas have influenced psychology and cultural discourse, but many of his theories are considered outdated and lack empirical evidence to support them. While some concepts, like the subconscious mind, are still relevant, other ideas, such as his views on sexuality and dream analysis, are viewed skeptically by modern psychologists.


Who tried to discover what motivates human behavior.?

Sigmund Freud was one of the pioneers in this area.

Related questions

What psychologists would have been most likely to use introspection?

Structuralists, like Wilhelm Wundt and Edward Titchener, would have been most likely to use introspection. They believed that by systematically analyzing one's own thoughts and experiences, they could uncover the basic elements of consciousness.


What psychologists focus in how the unconscious mind affects personality?

Psychologists interested in how the unconscious mind affects personality typically focus on psychoanalytic theory, which emphasizes how unconscious motives and conflicts shape behavior. They may explore concepts like defense mechanisms, repressed memories, and the role of early childhood experiences in shaping personality dynamics. This approach seeks to uncover hidden aspects of the self that influence thoughts, emotions, and behaviors.


Who are some experts in the sexology field?

Some experts in the sexology field include several famous psychologists and psychiatrists such as Carl Jung, Sigmund Freud and many other ones as well.


Who is the psychologist?

There are several famous psychologists. Some of the most famous are Sigmund Freud, Carl Jung, Erik Erikson, Ivan Pavlov, Jean Piaget, B. F. Skinner, and John Watson.


Who is the famous psychologist?

One famous psychologist is Sigmund Freud, known for his work in psychoanalysis and development of theories on the unconscious mind. Another well-known psychologist is Carl Jung, who is recognized for his contributions to analytical psychology and concepts such as the collective unconscious.


Who is a famous psychologist?

Sigmund Freud is one of the most famous and influential psychologists. Other famous psychologists include Jean Piaget, B.F. Skinner, Erik Erikson, and Ivan Pavlov. They have each contributed greatly to the field.


What is wrong with Freud's hypothesis on dreams?

Freud's hypothesis on dreams has been criticized for being overly focused on sexual and unconscious desires, and for lacking empirical evidence. Additionally, Freud's interpretation of dream symbols as universal has been challenged, as dreams may have more personal and context-specific meanings. Overall, Freud's theories on dreams have been largely replaced by more modern psychological perspectives.


Does research supported Freud's views on dreams?

The answer is both yes and no. Freud certainly laid the groundwork for dream analysis, on which successive generations of psychologists have built. But Freud's dogmatic emphasis on the sexual theory - that sexual repression is the basis of all neurosis, and the only theme of dreams - has been thoroughly debunked. See attached links for further study.


Which of Sigmund Freud ideas would not be accepted by most contemporary psychologists?

One idea of Sigmund Freud's that is not widely accepted by contemporary psychologists is his emphasis on the role of unconscious sexual and aggressive instincts (psychosexual theory) in shaping personality development. Many contemporary psychologists focus more on cognitive and social factors in understanding personality rather than Freud's emphasis on sexual and aggressive drives.


Who theorized that intelligence develops in stages that are related to age?

This has been a popular idea since the inception of psychoanalysis. Freud and Jung first theorized that personality was determined during childhood through a combination of imprints and conditioning. I know there are more modern psychologists who teach this, but Freud and Jung were probably the first.


Who are some good psychologists in California?

Some good psychologists in California belong to the California Board of Psychology. You can see a list of them and contact them at www.psychboard.ca.gov


Compared with Freud contemporary research psychologists are LESS likely to think of unconscious mental dynamics is involving A.Parallel processing B.repressive censoring C.implicit memory D.hemisphe?

B. repressive censoring. Modern research psychologists are more likely to view unconscious mental dynamics as involving parallel processing and implicit memory rather than repressive censoring due to reevaluation of Freud's ideas and advancements in cognitive psychology.