0
Why is valid psychology and psychiatry accepting the teachings of someone like Carl Jung who was mentally disturbed?
IAM
I assume you mean by valid psychology and psychiatry those schools of psychology that deny any and all subconscious processes. I find them not so much valid as incomplete and in denial of deeper psychological dimensions and structures. Behavioral Psychology denies the existence of a subconscious mind when it is clear that everyone has one. Everything about the mind is not rational but behavioral psychologists like to claim that it is either because the idea that they have a subconscious mind scares them so much that they are in denial or they are simply not intelligent enough to understand it.
What makes you say that Carl Jung was mentally disturbed? I don't see that in his biography and I don't see it in his work or writings. The Only thing that I see is a tremendously intelligent mind, able to see and understand complicated mental processes that men of lessor intelligence can't even see are there. I've read about 10 or so of His books and I see nothing but brilliant intelligence and no hint of any mental disturbance. I used to work as a Registered Nurse on psychiatric units in hospitals for 20 years so if there was any mental disturbance there I should have seen it.
Wiki User
∙ 12y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Is vegetable tales christian propaganda?
Veggie Tales teaches lessons on morals and relationships based upon teachings in the Bible, but these teachings can also be seen in the Torah and Koran as well.
Which part of the human personality did Sigmund Freud believe was made up of society's teachings concerning right and wrong?
Superego
Do the teachings of Carl Jung reveal that he was a schizophrenic and manic depressive?
Such assumptions have never been taken seriously, so no official diagnosis was declared.
Psychology and religion go together?
I can't speak to Religion in general, but to Christianity and the Bible.. *If we view psychology as "mental ploys and strategies" for treatment of illness, we have to be weary. Many common treatments can be very helpful and curative, but some are purely human opinion, even bordering on spiritism, conflict with Bible teachings and could even be dangerous . Each treatment would have to be examined individually to be sure it does not go against God's principles. *If we view psychology as a basic 'science of human behavior', it can be useful, since understanding people is an important part of a Christian's life. We're told at Proverbs 19:11 that "the insight of a man slows down his anger…" Insight is defined as "an understanding of the motivational forces behind one's actions". Understanding human behavior, and the reasons behind a behavior, can help us be forgiving and less angry over someone's questionable actions. Matthew 7:1-5 tells us to Stop judging others…." Why, do you look at the straw in your brother's eye, but do not consider the rafter in your own eye? 4 Or how can you say to your brother, 'Allow me to extract the straw from your eye'; when, look! a rafter is in your own eye? 5 Hypocrite! First extract the rafter from your own eye, and then you will see clearly how to extract the straw from your brother's eye. This involves SELF examination and understanding our OWN behavior. How much more valuable we can be to others if we first deal with our OWN issues, see our OWN faults, overcome our OWN improper thinking, before we find fault with anyone else. This involves some SELF analysis and insight.Matthew 7:12, the well known 'Golden rule' tells us to treat others the way WE want to be treated. If we think about it, we ALL want to be treated with consideration ; to be understood for who we really are. Only then can someone give us what we need. Therefore, in order to treat OTHERS the way they want to be treated, we have to KNOW what they want. That takes insight into the knowledge of THEIR human behavior. For psychology to be useful, it must harmonize with the Bible.(Jeremiah 8:9) So much of the Christian Greek scriptures involve "keeping an eye on the interests of others", "making our minds over", "putting on the new personality", involving our gaining insight into, understanding of, patience with others, all of which requires a knowledge of human behavior, our own and other people's. So Psychology and Religion CAN go together.
The Stream of Consciousness: William James?
William James was an American psychologist and philosopher born January 11, 1842. James came from a family of intellectual brilliance as his sister was the diarist Alice James, his brother the novelist Henry James, and his father Henry James, Sr. was a well-connected theologian. Additionally, James's godfather was Ralph Waldo Emerson. Growing up, James suffered from multiple physical ailments including that of the back, eyes, skin, and stomach. Additionally he dealt with bouts of depression and contemplation of suicide. In June 1869 James finally achieved his medical degree from Harvard University after several interruptions due to his ailments and a short-lived expedition up the Amazon River. Although a certified medical doctor, James never practiced any sort of medicine. During one of his breaks from medical school, James traveled to Germany for a cure to his “soul sickness.” It was in Germany that James realized his true interests were in the fields of philosophy and psychology. It was in 1872 after much philosophical searching that James considered himself cured.Psyography: William JamesWilliam James on TruthInfluences and TeachingsJames spent the extent of his academic career as a professor of Harvard University varying between physiology, psychology, anatomy, and philosophy until his retirement in 1907. James was the first professor to teach a course in psychology at an American University in 1875. With the influence of James's teachings and writings including the notable Principles of Psychology, psychology courses, journals, and societies began to spread throughout the country. With his research on the human memory, James disproved the 2,000 year old belief that memorizing any material would improve the memory. Through his self-experiment, he proved this to be untrue. James's chief influences on the field of psychology include his theories on functionalism, the self, stream of thought, free will, the unconscious, and emotion. Even after his retirement, James continued to lecture and publish new theories.Influences and ContributionsWilliam James and FunctionalismTheoriesOnes of James's most renowned theories involved the complexity of the stream of conscious thought. He theorized that consciousness is not merely a thing but a process or a flow of thoughts. James saw the consciousness as an infinite parade of emotions, images, sensations, and ideas that appear without a person's awareness and then pass away. It is a continuous stream of experiences and the consciousness's most important function is selecting to which experiences to pay attention. However these streams are not random or chaotic, there is a connected manner of order. The last though is connected to the thought before by some common rationale. There is an overlap between present, past, and future experiences. The current experience is connected to the last few experiences by a fringe that is continuously trailing off. Just at the beginning of the next experiences are starting to show up in the consciousness. With this theory, James saw thinking as an automated and evolutionary process that does not require any independent “thinker.”Other Resources on William JamesThe Meaning of TruthMemories and StudiesThe Moral Equivalent of WarThe Principles of PsychologyTalks to TeachersEssays in Radical EmpiricismThe Dilemma of DeterminismThe Varieties of Religious ExperienceThe Stream of ConsciousnessThe Will to BelieveReflections of William's James Essays
What do Christains believe they will gain by accepting Jesus and his teachings?
Christians believe that by accepting Jesus and his teachings, they will gain forgiveness of their sins, eternal life in heaven, a relationship with God, guidance for living a moral and fulfilling life, and hope for the future.
What do Cristians believe they will gain by accepting Jesus and his teachings?
Absolution and a place in Gods Kingdom.
What has the author S Stansfeld Sargent written?
S. Stansfeld Sargent has written: 'The basic teachings of the great psychologists' -- subject(s): Psychology 'Social psychology' -- subject(s): Social psychology
What are the teachings of Quran chapters that were revealed in Mecca?
The main teachings of Quran parts that was revealed inMecca (or Makkah) are calling people to worship Allah (god in English) the one and only one God with no partner, no son, no companion, and no associate. Reminding people with the second eternal life where they are either rewarded by accepting them in the Paradise or punished by pushing them into Hell fire.
What has the author David Seabury written?
David Seabury has written: 'How Jesus heals our minds today' -- subject(s): Lending library, Mental health, Religious Psychology, Teachings 'What makes us seem so queer?' -- subject(s): Neuroses, Psychoanalysis, Personality disorders, Personality 'How to get things done' -- subject(s): Applied Psychology, Psychology, Applied, Success 'Unmasking our minds' -- subject(s): Psychology 'How to worry successfully' -- subject(s): Worry 'Help yourself to happiness' -- subject(s): Mental health, Happiness
What has the author C Edward Barker written?
C. Edward Barker has written: 'Psychology's impact on the Christian faith' 'The church's neurosis and twentieth century revelations' -- subject(s): Christianity, Psychoanalysis and religion, Teachings
What are the teachings of animism?
teachings of animism
Do scientific theories about the creation of the universe contradict Islamic teachings?
Islam's teachings on the origin of the universe are essentially those of Judaism and Christianity, and therefore face the same challenges. It is not possible to accept scientific knowledge about the origins of the world, while accepting the literal truth of the Quran and the Bible, although the Quran is arguably more flexible in this regard than the Bible. However, many devout Muslims have become recognised scientists, demonstrating that, ultimately, rational persons do adjust to the contradictions that may exist in religious teachings.
What are the differences between the teachings of Paul and the teachings of the Church in Jerusalem headed by Jesus' brother James?
We do know that Paul taught that salvation came from faith alone, not from the Jewish law. Paul was clearly much more open to accepting non-Jews into the Church, and insisted that they need not be circumcised or follow Jewish dietary laws.We know little about the teachings of James, although of course modern Christianity assumes that he followed what is now orthodox Christian teachings. It seems that the Jerusalem Church, headed by James, taught that observance of the Old Testament laws was required for salvation. We need to be careful in reading James' Epistle, since this was probably not written by James himself, however it does appear to reflect his views about salvation by works and the Law.
Who made the Catholic teachings?
They are God's teachings.
What are Mirabai's main teachings?
teachings of mira bai
How were the teachings of the Torah important to judaism?
the teachings of the Torah are Judaism.
