0
Some people are under the impression that Ashkenazim cannot eat from the Hechsher of Badatz Beis Yosef due to the following stated reasons:
# Sefardi Shechita is unacceptable for Ashkenazim # Sefardi Halacha allows parts of the animals to be eaten that Ashkenazim cannot eat. # Badatz Beis Yosef allows in general certain heterim and Kullos that are not valid to Ashkenazim. 1) Regarding Hilchos Teraifos the Mechaber is considerably more
machmir than the Rema, and Sefardi shechita would be, if anything,
more mehudar. While the Rema does have certain chumros is Hilchos
Shechita such as forbidding hesitating during the second half of the
shechita, these should not be relevant to any experienced shochet.
2) There are certain organs that Sefardim eat and would be problematic
according to Halacha for Ashkenazim such as the udder, however this
would not be an issue with regular cuts of meat. While Sefardim did
continue doing nikur and eating the hindquarters of animals after
Ashkenazim lost the mesorah on the precise location of gid hanashe,
Today it is generally not financially worthwhile even for Sefardim and
one is unlikely to come across problematic cuts even from a Sefardi
hechsher.
3) I do not have any conclusive and authoritative information on what
kulos Badatz Beit Yosef might rely on, but if this is true it would
certainly be a problem. I don't think it is my place to judge
individual hechsherim, and certainly not in a public forum. [1] Rabbi Peretz Moncharsh, learned in the Yeshivos of Philadelphia, Brisk-R Dovid, Mir and Kollel La'asukei Shmaytsa. He currently lives in Beitar and is a Moreh Horaah on both the Ashkenazi and Sefardi Batei Horaah as well as the Rosh Kollel of Kollel Shaarei Horaah. Rabbi Moncharsh received Semicha from R' Zalman Nechenia Goldberg, R' Yaakov Tufik (the Sefaradi Rav of Beitar) and the Rabbanut. He did shimush by R' Tufik and by R' Yitzchok Kaufman.
Source: Jerusalem Kosher News - http://www.jerusalemkoshernews.com/
What else can I help you with?
What is shechita?
Shechita is a made up word.
Are you ashkenazim or sephardi?
Some Jews are ashkenazim and some are sefardim.
Do American Ashkenazim have more doctorate degrees per capita than Israeli Ashkenazim?
I don´t know but American Ashkenazim do have a higher GDP per capita than Israeli Ashkenazim.
What are some of the Jewish religions?
There is only one Jewish religion and all Jews follow the Torah as given to Moses on Mount Sinai over 3000 years ago. Over the centuries different areas developed different customs. Famous subdivisions include: - Sefardi: Jews who lived in Arab countries - Ashkenazim: Jews who lived in Europe - Temanim: Jews who lived in Yemen
Where is the root of word ashkenazim?
The word Ashkenazi is derived from the Hebrew word meaning Germany; as the Ashkenazim are descendants from Germany.
Is soya kosher for passover?
Not for Ashkenazim.
Has the gap between the Ashkenazi Jews and Sefardi Jews in Israel been increasing in recent years?
No. It has been consistently decreasing.
What was the main difference between the Ashkenazim and the Sephardim?
The main difference between Ashkenazim and Sephardim is their historical origins and cultural traditions. Ashkenazim are Jews of Eastern European descent, while Sephardim are Jews of Spanish and Portuguese descent. These different backgrounds have influenced their religious practices, language, and culinary traditions.
What are two major groups of followers in judism?
Sefardim and Ashkenazim
What does the Yiddish word 'Ashkenazim ' mean?
Ashkenazi Jews are from Eastern Europe.
Are Ashkenazim gentiles of genesis?
No, that's the wrong way around. The country or gentile people of Ashkenaz existed long before Jews ever came there. Western Jews are called Ashkenazim because they dwelt in that country for a time.
What is a German or polish Jew called?
It looks as if the word you are searching for is Ashkenaz (pl. Ashkenazim).
