answersLogoWhite

0

A Modest Proposal

Written by Jonathan Swift, this political satire may seem barbaric in it's concept. However, the outrageous concepts were introduced to point out the political machinations of the day to the general public. It is not for the tenderhearted as it is rather harsh.

504 Questions

From which source does the narrator of a modest proposal get his ideas?

The narrator of "A Modest Proposal" gets his ideas from observing the poverty and suffering of Irish people and the economic hardship faced during that time. He satirically suggests that selling infants as a food source to the wealthy could solve the country's problems.

According to the narrator why is his proposal unbiased?

The narrator believes his proposal is unbiased because he reveals the limitations and potential criticisms of his idea, shows empathy towards differing perspectives, and encourages critical analysis rather than enforcing a specific agenda.

What sentence best explains the difference in ideas between Swift the satirist and Swift the narrator in A Modest Proposal?

Swift the satirist uses exaggerated irony to criticize the British treatment of the Irish poor while Swift the narrator presents the absurd proposal of eating children as a serious solution to poverty, exposing the inhumane attitudes of the time. The difference lies in the satirical intention of the author versus the literal absurdity presented by the narrator within the text.

Where is understatement in modest proposal?

An example of understatement in "A Modest Proposal" by Jonathan Swift is when the narrator casually suggests that the Irish should sell their excess babies as a source of income, downplaying the horrifying proposal as if it is a reasonable solution to poverty and overpopulation. This technique helps to emphasize the absurdity and satire of the piece.

Why is the agreement necessary for setting the groundwork for the satire modest proposal?

The agreement sets the context for the satire by acknowledging the socio-political issues of poverty and overpopulation in Ireland at that time. By establishing these grim conditions as facts, Swift can then present his satirical proposal as a response to an extreme situation, highlighting the absurdity of the circumstances. This agreement serves as a foundation for the satirical commentary that follows.

What does Rra Tselane replay to Rra Keaja proposal reveal about Rra Tselane?

Rra Tselane's reply to Rra Keaja's proposal reveals that she values her independence and personal freedom. She declines the proposal by expressing her desire to pursue her own ambitions and dreams. This shows that she is confident in her own path and unwilling to sacrifice it for a relationship.

Why does Jonathan swift use satire in a modest proposal?

Jonathan Swift uses satire in "A Modest Proposal" to highlight the absurdity of British economic and social policies that were contributing to the impoverished conditions in Ireland. By presenting a horrific solution to the problem of poverty (suggesting that the Irish should sell their children as food), Swift aims to shock readers into recognizing the inhumanity of the situation and to spur action for real solutions. The use of satire allows Swift to criticize the oppressive attitudes of the ruling class in a way that is sharp, effective, and memorable.

How does swift make his argument more credible in a modest proposal?

Swift makes his argument more credible in "A Modest Proposal" by using a satirical and ironic tone to highlight the absurdity of his proposal, thereby engaging the reader and showing the extreme conditions faced by the Irish. By presenting statistical data and reasoning throughout the essay, Swift creates a logical framework to support his proposal, which adds a sense of realism to his satire. Additionally, he includes references to historical events and economic theories to enhance the credibility of his argument.

What did the narrator was a benefit of from the proposal?

The narrator saw the benefit of gaining independence and freedom from societal restrictions by accepting the proposal.

What agreement by all parties does swift seek to establish in the second paragraph of a modest proposal?

In the second paragraph of "A Modest Proposal," Swift seeks to establish an agreement among the Irish people, the English government, and the wealthy landlords that the poverty and suffering in Ireland must be addressed urgently. He does this by painting a grim picture of the dire circumstances faced by the Irish population.

How does the narrator propose to remedy the problem in A modest Proposal?

The narrator in "A Modest Proposal" by Jonathan Swift proposes that the impoverished Irish should sell their children as food to the wealthy to alleviate economic struggles and prevent overpopulation. This satirical suggestion aims to draw attention to the harsh realities of poverty and inequality in Ireland during that time.

Why do you think he gradually reveals the real nature of the proposal in the modest proposal?

Swift uses irony and satire in "A Modest Proposal" to shock readers into recognizing the harsh realities of poverty in Ireland. By gradually revealing the true nature of the proposal to consume children as a solution to poverty, Swift forces readers to confront their indifference towards the suffering of the poor and challenges societal attitudes towards the Irish.

Apex What is the practice that the narrator objects in A Modest Proposal?

The narrator objects to the practice of landlords mistreating and exploiting poor tenants in A Modest Proposal. He criticizes their indifference to the poverty and suffering of the Irish people, highlighting the need for a solution to address the underlying issues causing such hardships.

How does Swift most clearly use rhetoric in the passage A Modest Proposal?

In "A Modest Proposal," Swift uses rhetorical devices such as satire and irony to persuade the reader to reflect on the harsh reality of poverty and colonization in Ireland. By presenting his outrageous proposal to eat babies as a solution to Ireland's economic struggles, Swift employs shock value to provoke a critical response from the audience and highlight the indifference of the ruling class towards the poor.

How do you give an introduction in a proposal writing?

In the introduction of a proposal, start by addressing the problem or issue that the proposal aims to solve. Provide background information to give context and explain the relevance of the project. End the introduction with a clear and concise statement of the proposed solution or objective.

What is one way that A Modest Proposal is ironic?

The narrator's idea is ridiculous and immodest, not humble and acceptable.

List the 6 satirical benefits from swifts plan in a modest proposal?

  1. Reducing overpopulation by offering children as a food source.
  2. Providing economic relief for impoverished families by selling their children.
  3. Creating a new delicacy that would be in high demand.
  4. Improving political relations and unity by having a common goal of selling and consuming children.
  5. Addressing the issue of child neglect by encouraging parents to care for their children for monetary gain.
  6. Promoting self-reliance and entrepreneurship by allowing families to benefit from their own children.

Why might the facts the narrator reveals in the passage explain his willingness to come up with such barbaric proposal in the proposal?

The facts the narrator reveals show the desperation and destitution of the people, which might drive him to propose such a barbaric solution as a way to address the issue. The extreme circumstances depicted in the passage suggest that the narrator believes drastic measures are necessary to survive or improve their situation.

Why did Swift title his work A Modest Proposal?

Its irony helps the reader understand that such an idea is not acceptable and isn't meant to be taken seriously.

What is makes a modest proposal an effective satire?

"A Modest Proposal" by Jonathan Swift is effective satire because it uses irony and exaggeration to highlight the absurdity of British policies towards the Irish. By proposing a solution to the problem of poverty and overpopulation by suggesting that the Irish should sell their children as food, Swift is able to challenge the reader's complacency and expose the cruelty and indifference of those in power. The extreme nature of the proposal forces readers to confront the harsh realities of the situation and question their own beliefs and prejudices.

What are some weaknesses in Swifts a modest proposal?

One weakness in Swift's "A Modest Proposal" is the extreme, satirical nature of the proposal, which could potentially be misinterpreted or offend readers due to its shocking content. Additionally, some critics argue that the essay lacks a clear solution or constructive proposal for addressing the social and economic issues it critiques. Lastly, Swift's use of irony and sarcasm may make it difficult for some readers to grasp the true intent of the essay.

What is the six advantages of the proposal in a modest proposal?

In "A Modest Proposal" by Jonathan Swift, the advantages of the proposal include solving poverty by turning children into a source of income, reducing the number of Catholics in Ireland, alleviating overpopulation, providing economic benefits to the poor, addressing the burden of caring for children, and potentially improving the quality of meat consumed by the wealthy.

What is the plot of a modest proposal?

"A Modest Proposal" is a satirical essay written by Jonathan Swift in 1729. In it, Swift suggests that the poor in Ireland should sell their children as food to the rich landlords, as a solution to poverty and overpopulation. The proposal is meant to criticize England's oppressive policies towards Ireland and highlight the injustice faced by the Irish people.

When did you first realize Swift's modest proposal was not serious?

Swift's modest proposal was likely realized as not serious when the extreme nature of his proposal for solving poverty in Ireland — suggesting that the poor should sell their children as food — became evident. The absurdity and shocking disregard for human life in the proposal made it clear that Swift was using satire to critique British policies toward Ireland.

Swift a traditionalist was often skeptical of new ideas. In what way does a modest proposal reflect this attitude?

"A Modest Proposal" satirically criticizes societal issues like poverty and overpopulation by proposing a controversial solution of cannibalism. This reflects Swift's skepticism of traditional solutions and his willingness to challenge conventional thinking by presenting an extreme and absurd idea to highlight the flaws in society.