I think you mean 1858. Please see the link below
Look at the coins again. No Flying Eagle cents are dated 1886 or 1909. They were only struck from 1856 to 1858.
It depends on the variety and condition, but about $5-15 if worn and over a hundred dollars if it is in excellent condition. Do not clean your coin, cleaning coins will only cause them to lose value, not increase in value.
Assuming the coin has not been cleaned and "excellent condition" is EF-45, retail value should be about $150.00. I do suggest showing it to a dealer or collector for grading.
6-5-11>>> Assuming the coin is a 1857 Flying Eagle cent that has not been cleaned and in circulated condition, retail value for a low grade coin should be at least $25.00. I do suggest showing it to a dealer or collector for grading.
The value of a 1912 s penny depends greatly on the condition of the penny. In poor condition, it is only worth a penny, but in very good condition it may be worth $10 or more.
The value of a 1919 penny will vary depending on the condition of the coin. In poor condition, the value is .35 cents. In perfect condition, the value is $35.00.
The value of a 1803 large penny will depend on the condition of the coin. If the coin is in mint condition, the value is an estimated $256.00.
"double eagle penny" is kind of an oxymoron. A double eagle coin has a face value of $20. However, a gold coin is probably worth considerably more than face value.
The value of an orange one half penny varies by the year of the penny and the condition.
This is not enough information to give an accurate value amount. Need to know 'Type' of penny, 'Date' of penny and 'condition' of penny.
The value of a 1881 Indian head penny depends on the condition. As of 2014, one in good condition is worth $4.00, extremely fine condition is worth $20.00, and an uncirculated penny is worth approximately $50.00.
This coin in average circulated condition (grades below EF-40) has values from $25.00-$60.00 depending on the actual grade. It needs to be seen for an accurate value.