How does justice mclean deal with chief justice taney's argument in his dessent?

Answer 1

Justice McLean addresses Chief Justice Taney's dissent primarily by emphasizing the principles of liberty and the moral implications of slavery. He argues that the Constitution should be interpreted in a way that upholds human rights and justice for all individuals, rather than perpetuating the institution of slavery. McLean challenges Taney's narrow interpretation of citizenship and rights, advocating for a broader understanding that includes the dignity and humanity of enslaved individuals. Ultimately, McLean's dissent reflects a commitment to equality and the belief that the law must evolve to reflect ethical standards.