Should the supreme court be guided by the original meaning?

Answer 1

If you are referring to the original meaning of the Constitution and its amendments, yes the Supreme Court should be guided by the original meaning. The Constitution is basic American law and the Supreme Court does not have the authority nor the power to change it.

Answer 2

The question of whether the Supreme Court should be guided by the original meaning of the Constitution is a matter of interpretation. Some argue that interpreting the Constitution according to its original meaning ensures fidelity to the intentions of the framers. Others argue that the Constitution must be adapted to address modern realities and should be interpreted flexibly. Ultimately, the approach to constitutional interpretation should strike a balance between respecting the original intent and allowing for societal evolution.