No
The Union won the Civil War
The Union
Antietam (Sharpsburg) was more-or-less a draw. But the Confederates did retire from the field, so it was accounted a Union win. Similar was Murfreesboro (Stones River), but the same thing happened. In both cases, the Union advantage made a big impact on the evential outcome of the war.
The union won about 219 battles out of hundreds of battles in the Civil War from 1861-1865.
The battle of Shiloh was important because Tennessee secede from the union
Near the end of the first day of the Battle of Shiloh, Union forces were pinned with their backs to the Tennessee River. They managed to hold on and the battle was still undecided at that time. After the war PT Beauregard, who led the Confederates after Major General Albert S. Johnston was killed wrote about the battle. He reported the Union artillery commanded by Colonel J. D. Webster was the reason that the Confederates could not end the battle in victory on that first day.
The Battle of Shiloh(or Pittsburg Landing as it is called by the North) was a two-day battle fought on April 6-7, 1862. At the end of the first day the Confederates held the advantage. During the night more Union troops arrived by river boat. This allowed the Union Army to turn the tide of battle on the second day and ultimately win the battle.
Both Union and Confederates did not win
The Battle of Shiloh was a major Union Victory in the "West" (Tennessee) It was a much needed victory for at the same time Robert E. Lee and the Confederates were doing well in the East (Virginia) so Grant's win at Shiloh was a morale boost. It also moved the Union closer to its "western goal" of gaining control of the Mississippi River thus "dividing and conquering the South". However, Shiloh also highlighted a weakness in Grant and his career suffered heavily following the battle of Shiloh. Confederate forces would have inevitably won Shiloh if backups from Sherman had not arrived, before this occurred the confederates were winning. Shiloh is also significant as it was one of the most deadly battles in American history.
The Battle of Shiloh was a major Union Victory in the "West" (Tennessee) It was a much needed victory for at the same time Robert E. Lee and the Confederates were doing well in the East (Virginia) so Grant's win at Shiloh was a morale boost. It also moved the Union closer to its "western goal" of gaining control of the Mississippi River thus "dividing and conquering the South". However, Shiloh also highlighted a weakness in Grant and his career suffered heavily following the battle of Shiloh. Confederate forces would have inevitably won Shiloh if backups from Sherman had not arrived, before this occurred the confederates were winning. Shiloh is also significant as it was one of the most deadly battles in American history.
The Union had victory!both sides claimed victory but it was the union who actually won
The battle seemed to be a draw. But the Confederates did retreat South, and it is counted as a Union win.
Shiloh, Antietam, Gettysburg, Lookout Mountain, Atlanta, The Wilderness…
The Confederates had a big advantage - Grant didn't know they were there! Then the Confederate's top General was killed, and Grant got reinforcements. This Union win spelt the end of Confederate ascendancy in Western Tennessee.
They embarrassed the Union. The main thing that they won was morale for the war.
Shiloh