The arguments used to justify and oppose secession
The theory used by southerners to justify the secession of the southern states is that the states voluntarily entered into a union with each other, and should be able therefore to voluntarily withdraw from that union should they so desire, particularly since nothing in the US constitution states that the union is irrevocable.
The Northerners believed that it was unconstitutional and the Southerners believed that it was better for there way of life
Southerners justified secession primarily through the argument of states' rights, asserting that individual states had the sovereign authority to determine their own governance and laws, including the legality of slavery. They believed that the federal government was infringing upon their rights and way of life, especially with the growing abolitionist sentiment in the North. Additionally, many southerners framed their secession as a means of protecting their economic interests and social order, which they felt were threatened by Northern policies. These justifications were deeply intertwined with notions of honor, tradition, and a distinct Southern identity.
Declaration of Independence
no most of the southerners did not believe secession was illegal
They said the USA was formed as a voluntary group of states, and any one of them could quit when they wanted.
The arguments used to justify and oppose secession
state's rights
Southerners called for secession from the union......................................................................
Southerners called for secession from the union......................................................................
Southerners called for secession from the union......................................................................
State's rights
The Northerners believed that it was unconstitutional and the Southerners believed that it was better for there way of life
The Northerners believed that it was unconstitutional and the Southerners believed that it was better for there way of life
secession
The theory used by southerners to justify the secession of the southern states is that the states voluntarily entered into a union with each other, and should be able therefore to voluntarily withdraw from that union should they so desire, particularly since nothing in the US constitution states that the union is irrevocable.