In circulated condition, a 1976 US $2 bill is only worth face value.
The other bill, though, must have a different date because there are no 1958 US banknotes of any denomination. Please check its date again and look for the question "What is the value of a [date] US 2 dollar bill?" for values.
$2
2 dollars.
About $3.00
2 dollars
The US didn't print any bills dated 1958.
$2
2 dollars.
About $3.00
2 dollars
$5.00 in U.S. dollars
The exact value of a 1976 Hawaii dollar would actually be dependent upon a number of factors. Most importantly the condition of the bill.
The US didn't print any bills dated 1958.
It's still worth two dollars.
The series 1976 $2 bill is extremely common and is worth face value only.
Unless it's crisp and uncirculated, face value only
You probably mean 1976, and it is just worth $2.
Face value if circulated. Uncirculated, around $3.