How do you catch fish on HorseIsle?

Answer 1

When you hook a big fish, reel it in slowly, or the fish will get away. Only reel it in one or two clicks at a time. Click again when the fish is not being pulled up, and is swimming forward or down. Keep doing this at a steady pace, and you will soon catch the fish.

A small tip: If you only want big fish and you hook either a normal or a small one, just click "Go Fishing!" again and you will not lose a worm to get a fish you don't want. I tried this and it didn't work for me... personally, I'm not sure how to catch one at all.

Answer 2

You have to buy a fishing pole, then find a place filled with water then click the water and there will be a drop down list, from that list select: fish if this does not work than you don't have a fishing pole yet.

Answer 3

Its really hard to find one. You can trade with other players or buy one from the red barns. But if you want to catch one you just go to an isle without a town and if you see a horse you click on it to catch it. I suggest you "Look" at it first, this way you won't catch a breed you don't want, like with me, I caught a pony, and I was looking for a fast horse. For me, the best, and the most horses are in Twin Rivers. When you start the mini-game to catch the horse you just need to put the rope on the wild horse. But it needs to be put on the head.