Go to NLC and Visit Lita Lawless. (You must be over level 80) She will have a quest for you to get 30 Lucky Charms(can be obtained by killing Leprechauns) Then you need to get 30 Soiled Rags for the next quest(Can be obtained by killing Elderly Wraiths). Now the hard part begins... You need to get a headless horsemans head by killing Headless Horseman(Boss). Then BigFoot's Toe.(The hardest part) You now have the dep star after you completed all these quests
Silver Deputy Stakes was created in 1997.
Arwen the fairy
The easiest way is to buy it from a shop.
The Deputy Sheriff's Star - 1914 was released on: USA: 9 May 1914
Silver Star was created in 1932.
Cash Shop
Silver Star Reversi happened in 2008.
Silver Bauhinia Star was created in 1997.
Silver Star Carousel was created in 1928.
Silver Star Holidays was created in 1918.
Silver Star Holidays ended in 2011.
http://global.hidden-street.net/items/throwing-star/icicles