When you travel to Counterfeit Island you go right past the under ground tunnel keep going right and you'll see it.
the thief is in the jazz cafe next to the stage.
In the garbage near the Jazz Cafe
Hes hiding in the Jazz Cafe
he is in the under ground jazz cafe
go to the jazz cafe
They are singing because they are telling you to go to the Jazz Cafe.
You have to go to the jazz cafe and he is at the stage
You show them the picture of the theif, then they whistle, meaning he is in the jazz cafe!
you have to talk to the mimes and they will motion you to go to the jazz cafe.
You ask the mimes who hum a tune indicating to go to the Jazz Cafe.
he goes to the jazz cafe on down town. he's not the blacwidow, just to tell you.
look for 2 bins to the left of 'all that jazz cafe' the one to the right has two tickets at the bottom.