Depends on where you try to sell it. For example, try and take it to a Gander Mountain and they'll tell how great of a gun it is (which I agree) but will then tell you that they have a policy in place to not buy Ithaca model 51's. The reason is the replacement parts are too expensive; thus making the gun, in there eyes, essentially worthless. Consider it a "niche" market. Someone has to be looking for THAT gun, not just A gun.
An Ithaca model 51 magnum 3 inch shotgun is worth $275-$325, depending on condition.
Send me your email & I'll send you a scan of the Ithaca model 51 exploded view & bolt buffer.
If the Model 51 is in very good condition it should bring $250 - $300.
Browning never made a Model 51 shotgun.
This model sells anywhere from 250 dollars to 500 dollars. The determining factors are, as always what kind of condition the firearm is in.
i had a model 51 410 shotgun given to me and wanted to learn about its value
To remove the plug from an Ithaca Model 51 autoloader shotgun, first ensure the firearm is unloaded and pointed in a safe direction. Disassemble the shotgun by removing the barrel and then locate the plug, which is housed in the magazine tube. Use a flathead screwdriver to unscrew the retaining screw if present, then carefully pull the plug out of the magazine tube. Reassemble the shotgun once the plug is removed, ensuring all parts are secure.
Depends on where you try to sell it. For example, try and take it to a Gander Mountain and they'll tell how great of a gun it is (which I agree) but will then tell you that they have a policy in place to not buy Ithaca model 51's. The reason is the replacement parts are too expensive; thus making the gun, in there eyes, essentially worthless. Consider it a "niche" market. Someone has to be looking for THAT gun, not just A gun.
http://www.ithacagun.com/model51schematic.html
good condition about 2500.00
brand new when it was made 239.00 there still some collectors that will pay a good price for it .....look on shotgun world website
Best to let a gunsmith do it.